Macro-environment strongly interacts with warming in a global analysis of decomposition

Sarah Schwieger,Ellen Dorrepaal,Matteo Petit Bon,Vigdis Vandvik,Elizabeth le Roux,Maria Strack,Yan Yang,Susanna Venn,Johan van den Hoogen,Fernando Valiño,Haydn J.D. Thomas,Mariska te Beest,Satoshi Suzuki,Alessandro Petraglia,Isla H. Myers-Smith,Tariq Muhammad Munir,Anders Michelsen,Jørn Olav Løkken,Qi Li,Takayoshi Koike,Kari Klanderud,Ellen Haakonsen Karr,Ingibjörg Svala Jónsdóttir,Robert D. Hollister,Annika Hofgaard,Ibrahim A. Hassan,Wang Genxu,Nina Filippova,Thomas W. Crowther,Karin Clark,Casper T. Christiansen,Angelica Casanova-Katny,Michele Carbognani,Stef Bokhorst,Katrín Björnsdóttir,Johan Asplund,Inge Althuizen,Rocío Alonso,Juha Alatalo,Evgenios Agathokleous,Rien Aerts,Judith M. Sarneel

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.04.03.587921

2024-04-05

Abstract:Empirical studies worldwide show substantial variability in plant litter decomposition responses to warming, leaving the overall impact of climate change on this process uncertain. We conducted a meta-analysis of 109 experimental warming studies across seven continents, utilizing natural and standardized plant material, to assess the overarching effect of warming on decomposition and identify potential moderating factors. Warming influences decomposition differently across macro-environmental gradients of moisture and temperature. Negative warming effects on decomposition in warmer, low-moisture areas were counterbalanced by the positive, though not significant, warming effects in colder areas, resulting in an overall non-significant effect. We determine that at least 5.2 degrees of warming is required for a significant increase in decomposition. This is particularly relevant given the past decade’s global warmth in higher latitudes, holding a significant proportion of terrestrial carbon. Low-quality plant litter was more sensitive to warming. Therefore, future vegetation changes toward low-quality, temperature-sensitive plants could increase carbon release and reduce the net supply of stored organic matter in the soil by increasing the decomposition of low-quality litter with warming. Our findings emphasize the connection between warming responses, macro-environment, and litter characteristics, refining predictions of climate change’s consequences on key ecosystem processes and its contextual dependencies.

Ecology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper attempts to address the impact of global warming on the decomposition process of plant litter and its variation patterns under different macro-environmental conditions. Specifically, the researchers used a meta-analysis approach, synthesizing data from 109 experimental warming studies across 7 continents, utilizing both natural and standardized plant materials to assess the overall effect of warming on the decomposition process and identify potential regulatory factors.

The study found that in warmer and lower humidity regions, warming had a negative impact on decomposition; whereas in colder regions, although the impact of warming on decomposition was positive, it was not significant. Overall, warming did not have a significant effect on decomposition. However, the study pointed out that at least a 5.2-degree increase in temperature is required to significantly increase the decomposition rate. Additionally, low-quality plant litter was found to be more sensitive to warming. Therefore, future shifts in vegetation towards low-quality, temperature-sensitive plants may accelerate the decomposition of these low-quality litters, thereby increasing carbon release and reducing the net supply of organic matter stored in the soil.

In summary, the paper aims to reveal the connections between warming responses, macro-environmental conditions, and litter characteristics through comprehensive analysis, to improve predictions of the impact of future climate change on key ecosystem processes and their context dependency.