rRNA Operon Improves Species-Level Classification of Bacteria and Microbial Community Analysis Compared to 16S rRNA

Sohyoung Won,Seoae Cho,Heebal Kim

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.04.01.587560

2024-04-01

Abstract:Precise identification of species is fundamental in microbial genomics, crucial for understanding the microbial communities. While the 16S rRNA gene, particularly its V3-V4 regions, has been extensively employed for microbial identification, however has limitations in achieving species-level resolution. Advancements in long-read sequencing technologies have highlighted the rRNA operon as a more accurate marker for microbial classification and analysis than the 16S rRNA gene. This study aims to compare the accuracy of species classification and microbial community analysis using the rRNA operon versus the 16S rRNA gene. We evaluated the species classification accuracy of the rRNA operon,16S rRNA gene, and 16S rRNA V3-V4 region using a BLAST based method and a -mer matching based method with public data available from NCBI. We further preformed simulations to model microbial community analysis. We accessed the performance using each marker in community composition estimation and differential abundance analysis. Our findings demonstrate that the rRNA operon offers an advantage over the 16S rRNA gene and its V3-V4 region for species-level classification within genus. When applied to microbial community analysis, the rRNA operon enables a more accurate determination of composition. Using the rRNA operon yielded more reliable results in differential abundance analysis as well.

Microbiology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper primarily explores the application of rRNA operons in bacterial species classification and microbial community analysis, aiming to compare their accuracy at the species level with that of traditional 16S rRNA genes and their V3-V4 regions. The study points out that although the 16S rRNA gene (especially the V3-V4 region) is widely used in microbial identification, it has limitations in achieving species-level resolution. With the development of long-read sequencing technologies, the advantages of rRNA operons as more precise markers for microbial classification and analysis are gradually becoming apparent.

The study evaluated the performance of rRNA operons, 16S rRNA genes, and the 16S rRNA V3-V4 region in species classification accuracy using two methods: BLAST and k-mer matching, and conducted experiments using publicly available data from the NCBI database. The results showed that rRNA operons significantly outperformed 16S rRNA genes and their V3-V4 regions in species classification accuracy, particularly in intra-genus species classification. Additionally, rRNA operons demonstrated higher accuracy in predicting microbial community composition and differential abundance analysis, allowing for more precise determination of community composition and producing more reliable results in differential abundance analysis.

The paper further validated these findings using simulated microbial community data and actual human gut microbiome data, demonstrating that rRNA operons have a clear advantage in predicting species proportions and conducting differential abundance analysis. The study emphasizes that while using rRNA operons can improve classification accuracy, their sequencing costs may be higher, so the choice of method should consider the required resolution and budget. For studies requiring precise species-level analysis, such as biomarker discovery or microbiome-based therapies, rRNA operons are the better choice; whereas for cases that do not require species-level analysis or can accept lower accuracy, 16S rRNA may be a more economical option. In disease-related microbial community studies, the importance of rRNA operons is particularly prominent, as they can provide more accurate species differentiation, which is crucial for accurately understanding microbial changes in disease states.