Abstract:In many species, individuals of the same sex exhibit different mating behaviours, a phenomenon known as alternative mating tactics (AMTs). These AMTs may occur in species in which morphology prevents individuals from adopting different tactics (fixed expression of AMTs) as well as in species in which individuals can alternate between them (flexible expression of AMTs). Regardless of the way different mating tactics are expressed, a key point to understanding the selective forces driving AMT evolution relies on identifying differences in the reproductive success between tactics. Empirical studies often indicate that individuals adopting the main tactic (generally the more aggressive) have higher mating success than those adopting the secondary tactic. However, while this is expected for species showing flexible expression of AMTs, the same should not hold for species showing fixed expression of AMTs. In species with fixed expression of AMTs, individuals adopting each tactic have morphological specialisations in acquiring mates that may be responsible for eliminating differences in reproductive success between tactics. Despite such expectations, a comprehensive investigation across species regarding differences in the reproductive success of AMTs is lacking. Using a meta‐analytical approach, we investigated if there is a difference in the reproductive success between tactics and whether this difference is related to how these tactics are expressed (fixed or flexible). We focused on males since information on reproductive success for females with AMTs is still scarce. We hypothesised that (i) males adopting the main tactic have higher reproductive success than males adopting the secondary tactic, and (ii) the difference in reproductive success between tactics will be higher in species with flexible rather than fixed expression of AMTs. When all species were pooled, we found that males adopting the main tactic had a similar reproductive success to males adopting the secondary mating tactic. However, this trend changed between species with fixed and flexible expression of AMTs. In species with flexible expression of AMTs, males exhibiting the main tactic have higher mating success than those adopting secondary tactics, while in species with fixed expression of AMTs, males adopting distinct tactics have similar reproductive success. Thus, the widespread assumption that males adopting the main tactic have higher reproductive success than males adopting the secondary tactic may be restricted to species in which individuals can alternate between tactics during their lifespan. However, we found that most data on the reproductive success of males adopting AMTs is restricted to short reproductive windows and may not reflect differences in lifetime reproductive success between tactics. Therefore, we highlight the importance of examining the selective pressures associated with fixed and flexible expression of AMTs on lifetime reproductive success to attain a deeper understanding of AMT evolution.

Spatial structure could explain the maintenance of alternative reproductive tactics in tree cricket males

Alternative mating strategies in the Wellington tree weta expressed via genetic polymorphism for precocial male maturation

Persistence of alternative reproductive tactics: a test of game theoretic predictions

Genetically identical mice express alternative reproductive tactics depending on social conditions in the field

Polymorphism Maintenance in a Spatially Structured Population: A Two-Locus Genetic Model of Niche Construction

Alternative Mating Tactics in Socially Monogamous Prairie Voles, Microtus ochrogaster

Behavioural Movement Strategies in Cyclic Models

Decoupling of female phonotaxis and mating propensity in a tree cricket

Availability of mates and food influence the plasticity in strategies mediating life‐history tradeoffs in an insect

Variation in grouping patterns, mating systems and social structure: what socio-ecological models attempt to explain

Genetic variation in reproductive investment across an ephemerality gradient in Daphnia pulex

A meta‐analysis on alternative mating tactics: when the main and the alternative yield similar reproductive success

A Genetic Polymorphism Underlying Alternative Reproductive Tactics in Eurycea Salamanders

Intraspecific alternative phenotypes contribute to variation in species' strategies for growth

Mate choice strategies in a spatially-explicit model environment

A Theoretical Comparison of Alternative Male Mating Strategies in Cephalopods and Fishes

Spatial structure imposes sex-specific costs but does not reduce interlocus sexual conflict

Metabolic rate associates with, but does not generate covariation between, behaviours in western stutter-trilling crickets, Gryllus integer

The maintenance of genetic polymorphism underlying sexually antagonistic traits

Competing adaptations maintain nonadaptive variation in a wild cricket population

Spatio-Temporal Dynamics of Field Cricket Calling Behaviour: Implications for Female Mate Search and Mate Choice