Redefining the role of Hypoxia-inducible factors (HIFs) in oxygen homeostasis

Clemente F. Arias,Francisco J. Acosta,Federica Bertocchini,Cristina Fernańdez-Arias

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.03.15.585157

2024-03-16

Abstract:Hypoxia-inducible factors (HIFs) are key regulators of intracellular oxygen homeostasis. The marked increase in HIFs activity in hypoxia as compared to normoxia, together with their transcriptional control of primary metabolic pathways, motivated the widespread view of HIFs as responsible for the cell’s metabolic adaptation to hypoxic stress. In this work, we suggest that this prevailing model of HIFs regulation is misleading. We propose an alternative model focused on understanding the dynamics of HIFs’ activity within its physiological context. Our model suggests that HIFs would not respond to but rather prevent the onset of hypoxic stress by regulating the traffic of electrons between catabolic substrates and oxygen. The explanatory power of our approach is patent in its interpretation of the Warburg effect, the tendency of tumor cells to favor anaerobic metabolism over respiration, even in fully aerobic conditions. This puzzling behavior is currently considered as an anomalous metabolic deviation. Our model predicts the Warburg effect as the expected homeostatic response of tumor cells to the abnormal increase in metabolic demand that characterizes malignant phenotypes. This alternative perspective prompts a redefinition of HIFs’ function and underscores the need to explicitly consider the cell’s metabolic activity in understanding its responses to changes in oxygen availability.

Cell Biology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem this paper attempts to address is whether the role of hypoxia-inducible factors (HIFs) in the regulation of intracellular oxygen homeostasis has been misunderstood. The traditional view holds that HIFs are primarily activated under hypoxic conditions to help cells adapt to low oxygen environments. However, the authors propose a new model suggesting that the role of HIFs is not merely a response to hypoxia but involves regulating the transfer of electrons from metabolic substrates to oxygen, preventing an imbalance in intracellular oxygen homeostasis. Specifically, the function of HIFs is to prevent rather than merely respond to hypoxic stress.

### Main Contributions of the Paper:
1. **Redefining the Function of HIFs**:
- The authors propose a new model suggesting that HIFs are active not only under hypoxic conditions but also play a crucial regulatory role under various oxygen concentrations.
- HIFs maintain the balance of electron transfer within cells by regulating key steps in metabolic pathways such as glycolysis, the tricarboxylic acid cycle (TCA cycle), and fermentation, thereby preventing oxygen saturation and the accumulation of metabolic intermediates.

2. **Explaining the Warburg Effect**:
- Traditionally, the tendency of tumor cells to undergo anaerobic metabolism even under aerobic conditions (the Warburg effect) has been viewed as an abnormal metabolic behavior.
- The authors' new model predicts that the Warburg effect is actually a normal physiological response of tumor cells to abnormally increased metabolic demands, rather than an abnormal phenomenon.

3. **Emphasizing the Importance of Metabolic Activity**:
- The authors point out that understanding the cellular response to oxygen availability must take into account the cell's metabolic activity. The regulatory role of HIFs is closely related not only to oxygen concentration but also to the cell's metabolic demands.
- This perspective challenges the traditional binary model (i.e., normoxia and hypoxia) and emphasizes the importance of intermediate oxygen levels.

### Conclusion:
By redefining the function of HIFs, this paper provides a more comprehensive framework for understanding the regulation of intracellular oxygen homeostasis. This new perspective not only helps explain long-considered abnormal metabolic phenomena such as the Warburg effect but also offers new directions for future research and potential therapeutic interventions.