Abstract:Delimitations of species are crucial for correct and precise identification of taxa. Unfortunately “species” is more a subjective than an objective concept in taxonomic practice due to difficulties in revealing patterns of infra- or inter-specific variations. Molecular phylogenetic studies at the population level solve this problem and lay a sound foundation for DNA barcoding. In this paper we exemplify the necessity of adopting a phylogenetic concept of species in DNA barcoding for tree peonies (Paeonia sect. Moutan). We used 40 samples representing all known populations of rare and endangered species and several populations of widely distributed tree peonies. All currently recognized species and major variants have been included in this study. Four chloroplast gene fragments, i.e. ndhF, rps16-trnQ, trnL-F and trnS-G (a total of 5040 characters, 96 variable and 69 parsimony-informative characters) and one variable and single-copy nuclear GPAT gene fragment (2093–2197 bp, 279 variable and 148 parsimony-informative characters) were used to construct phylogenetic relationships among the taxa. The evolutionary lineages revealed by the nuclear gene and the chloroplast genes are inconsistent with the current circumscriptions of P. decomposita, P. jishanensis, P. qiui, and P. rockii based on morphology. The inconsistencies come from (1) significant chloroplast gene divergence but little nuclear GPAT gene divergence among population systems of P. decomposita + P. rockii, and (2) well-diverged nuclear GPAT gene but little chloroplast gene divergence between P. jishanensis and P. qiui. The incongruence of the phylogenies based on the chloroplast genes and the nuclear GPAT gene is probably due to the chloroplast capture event in evolutionary history, as no reproductive barriers exist to prevent inter-specific hybridization. We also evaluated the suitability of these genes for use as DNA barcodes for tree peonies. The variability of chloroplast genes among well-defined species or population systems of a species complex is 4.82 times the figure within the groups, and the GPAT gene is twice as variable between the groups as within the groups. The number of completely divergent sites is sufficient to mark the two subsections, the two species in subsection Delavayanae, and the well-divergent species in subsection Vaginatae. But the genes currently used either from the chloroplast genome or from the nuclear genome alone cannot correctly assign samples of P. decomposita, P. jishanensis, P. qiui, or P. rockii to the species as currently defined. We conclude that (1) DNA barcoding should be based on prior phylogenetic studies to understand the evolutionary lineages and how well the taxonomic species correspond to the lineages; (2) it is unlikely to find a single short fragment as a barcode for every plant and such a fragment could result in misidentification when a chloroplast capture event happened in the evolutionary history of plants like tree peonies; and (3) we suggest striving for a universal marker at the familial level and locally universal barcodes within a family instead of looking for a universal barcode for all plants.

DNA barcoding and species delimitation based on four Chloroplast loci to identify species within the Elaeocarpaceae family

Species Delimitation in Orychophragmus (brassicaceae) Based on Chloroplast and Nuclear Dna Barcodes

Testing the Complete Plastome for Species Discrimination, Cryptic Species Discovery and Phylogenetic Resolution in Cephalotaxus (Cephalotaxaceae)

Multiple multilocus DNA barcodes from the plastid genome discriminate plant species equally well

DNA Barcoding of Invasive Terrestrial Plant Species in India

The specific DNA barcodes based on chloroplast genes for species identification of Theaceae plants

Comparative Plastomics of Plantains (Plantago, Plantaginaceae) as a Tool for the Development of Species-Specific DNA Barcodes

DNA Barcoding: Species Delimitation in Tree Peonies.

DNA barcode developement based on chloroplast and ITS genes for species identification of endangered and threated species of Western Ghats, India

Plastome Data Provide Insights into Intra and Interspecific Diversity and Ndh Gene Loss in Capparis (Capparaceae)

DNA Barcodes for Accurate Identification of Selected Medicinal Plants (Caryophyllales): Toward Barcoding Flowering Plants of the United Arab Emirates

Are nuclear loci ideal for barcoding plants? A case study of genetic delimitation of two sister species using multiple loci and multiple intraspecific individuals

Construction of a New Molecular Barcode for Discriminating Plants and Animals with a Close Genetic Relationship

Comparative genomics and phylogenetic analysis of chloroplast genomes of Asian Caryodaphnopsis taxa (Lauraceae)

Molecular taxonomy via DNA barcodes for species identification in selected genera of Fabaceae

Molecular Discrimination and Phylogenetic Relationships of Physalis Species Based on ITS2 and rbcL DNA Barcode Sequence

The Rps4 Locus As an Alternative Marker for Barcoding Bryo-Phytes: Eva-Luation Based on Data Mining from GenBank

Comparative Analysis of Plastomes in Elsholtzieae: Phylogenetic Relationships and Potential Molecular Markers

Identification of effective DNA barcodes for Triticum plants through chloroplast genome-wide analysis

The specific DNA barcodes based on chloroplast genes for species identification of Orchidaceae plants

Discriminating Plants Using the DNA Barcode Rbclb: an Appraisal Based on a Large Data Set.