Assessing Individual Sensitivity to the Thermal Grill Illusion: A Two-Dimensional Adaptive Psychophysical Approach

Camila Sardeto Deolindo,Jesper Fischer Ehmsen,Arthur S. Courtin,Alexandra G. Mitchell,Camilla E. Kraenge,Niia Nikolova,Micah G. Allen,Francesca Fardo

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.03.14.585017

2024-03-14

Abstract:In the thermal grill illusion (TGI), the spatial alternation of non-noxious warm and cold temperatures elicits burning sensations that resemble the presence of noxious stimuli. Previous research has largely relied on the use of specific temperature values (i.e., 20°C and 40°C) to study this phenomenon in both healthy individuals and patient populations. However, this methodology fails to account for inter-individual differences in thermal sensitivity, limiting the precision with which TGI responses can be evaluated across diverse populations. To address this gap, we created a Two-Dimensional Thermal Grill Calibration (2D-TGC) protocol, enabling an efficient and precise estimation of the combinations of warm and cold temperatures needed to elicit burning sensations tailored to each individual. By applying the 2D-TGC protocol in 43 healthy participants, we demonstrated key findings: (1) The TGI can be thresholded using an adaptive psychophysical method. (2) Multiple combinations of warm and cold temperatures can elicit this phenomenon. (3) The protocol facilitated the identification of temperature combinations that elicit TGI with varying levels of probability, intensity, and perceived quality ranging from freezing cold to burning hot. (4) TGI responsivity can be quantified as a continuous variable, moving beyond the conventional classification of individuals as responders vs. non-responders based on arbitrary temperature values. The 2D-TGC offers a comprehensive approach to investigate the TGI across populations with altered thermal sensitivity, and can be integrated with other methods (e.g., neuroimaging) to elucidate the mechanisms responsible for perceptual illusions in the thermo-nociceptive system.

Neuroscience

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper mainly discusses the perception psychology of the Thermal Grill Illusion (TGI), which is a phenomenon that causes a burning sensation through alternating non-harmful cold and hot stimuli. In the study, the authors developed a two-dimensional Thermal Grill Calibration (2D-TGC) protocol to accurately estimate the cold and hot temperature combinations needed for individuals to perceive the burning sensation using adaptive psychophysical methods. By applying this protocol to 43 healthy participants, the following key findings were obtained:

1. TGI can be thresholded using adaptive psychophysical methods.
2. The cold and hot temperature combinations that induce TGI have diversity.
3. The protocol can identify temperature combinations of different probabilities, intensities, and perceptual qualities, ranging from freezing to scalding.
4. The reactivity of TGI can be quantified as a continuous variable, surpassing the traditional method of categorizing individuals simply as responders or non-responders based on fixed temperature values.

The paper points out that previous studies have relied on specific temperature values (such as 20°C and 40°C), neglecting individual differences in temperature sensitivity, which limits the accuracy of assessing TGI responses. The 2D-TGC method provides a comprehensive approach to studying TGI in different populations with thermosensitivity and can be combined with other methods, such as neuroimaging, to reveal the mechanisms of perceptual illusions in the thermal pain perception system.