Nieves López-Pagán,José S. Rufián,Julien Luneau,María-Antonia Sánchez-Romero,Laurent Aussel,Simon van Vliet,Javier Ruiz-Albert,Carmen R. Beuzón
Abstract:Bacteria respond to changing environments by altering gene expression. Some responses display probabilistic cell-to-cell variation within isogenic populations. A few paradigmatic examples in animal pathogens have demonstrated that this phenotypic heterogeneity has biological relevance for virulence. We investigate single-cell flagellar expression in relation to type III secretion expression in the plant pathogen and describe that both systems undergo phenotypic heterogeneity throughout plant colonization. We establish that high expression of these system carries growth penalties. Stochastic, spatial and time factors shape dynamics of a phenotypically diverse population which displays division of labor during colonization: T3SS bacteria effectors act as ‘common goods’ to suppress immunity, allowing the increase of motile bacteria that actively leave the infected tissue before necrosis. This study provides a comprehensive view of how processes underlying bacterial specialization play out in the context of complex and changing environments of biological and applied relevance such as host colonization.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to explore the relationship between flagellar expression and type - III secretion system (T3SS) expression during the colonization process of the plant pathogen **Pseudomonas syringae** in the host, as well as their impacts on bacterial adaptability and pathogenicity. Specifically, the researchers focused on the following aspects:
1. **Phenotypic heterogeneity of flagellar expression**:
- The researchers found that under different growth conditions, including in laboratory media and the phyllosphere environment of plants, there is significant inter - cellular variation (phenotypic heterogeneity) in the flagellar gene expression of **P. syringae**. Even in a homologous population, differences in flagellar gene expression were observed. Some bacteria expressed high - level flagellar genes, while others did not express or had a lower expression level.
2. **Mutual regulation between flagellar expression and T3SS expression**:
- Through the study of double - reporter strains (simultaneously labeled with the flagellar gene *fliC* and the T3SS gene *hrpL*), the researchers revealed an inverse regulatory relationship between flagellar expression and T3SS expression. That is, bacteria with high - level T3SS expression usually do not express flagella, and vice versa. This inverse regulation may contribute to the adaptability of bacteria in different environments.
3. **Impacts of flagellar expression and T3SS expression on bacterial growth**:
- The study found that the expression of either flagella or T3SS has a negative impact on bacterial growth. For example, bacteria with high - level flagellar gene expression have a slower growth rate, and bacteria with high - level T3SS gene expression are at a disadvantage in the competition within plants.
4. **Spatially structured phenotypic specialization**:
- In the micro - colonies on the plant phyllosphere, the spatial distribution of flagellar expression and T3SS expression shows dynamic changes. In the early infection stage, bacteria mainly express T3SS, while in the late infection stage, flagellar expression gradually increases. This spatial distribution pattern indicates that there is a division of labor and cooperation among bacteria during the colonization process. Bacteria expressing T3SS are responsible for suppressing plant immunity, while bacteria expressing flagella are responsible for actively leaving the infected tissue to avoid tissue necrosis.
5. **Ability to actively leave the infected tissue**:
- The study also found that flagella - expressing bacteria can more effectively and actively leave plant leaves in the later stage of infection, which may help bacteria to find new hosts or niches.
In summary, through detailed single - cell analysis, this paper reveals the complex regulatory mechanisms of flagellar expression and T3SS expression during the colonization process of **P. syringae** in the host, as well as their impacts on bacterial adaptability and pathogenicity. These findings are helpful for in - depth understanding of the survival strategies of plant pathogens and their interaction mechanisms with the host.