Learning from the COVID-19 pandemic: a systematic review of mathematical vaccine prioritization models

Gilberto Gonzalez-Parra,Md Shahriar Mahmud,Claus Kadelka

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.03.04.24303726

2024-03-07

Abstract:As the world becomes ever more connected, the chance of pandemics increases as well. The recent COVID-19 pandemic and the concurrent global mass vaccine roll-out provides an ideal setting to learn from and refine our understanding of infectious disease models for better future preparedness. In this review, we systematically analyze and categorize mathematical models that have been developed to design optimal vaccine prioritization strategies of an initially limited vaccine. As older individuals are disproportionately affected by COVID-19, the focus is on models that take age explicitly into account. The lower mobility and activity level of older individuals gives rise to non-trivial trade-offs. Secondary research questions concern the optimal time interval between vaccine doses and spatial vaccine distribution. This review showcases the effect of various modeling assumptions on model outcomes. A solid understanding of these relationships yields better infectious disease models and thus public health decisions during the next pandemic.

Infectious Diseases (except HIV/AIDS)

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is how to design the optimal vaccine priority vaccination strategy in the case of limited vaccine supply. Specifically, the research focuses on the following aspects:

1. **Age - stratified vaccine distribution**: In the case where the population is stratified by age, how to optimally distribute the limited vaccines. Since the elderly are more affected by COVID - 19, many models specifically consider the age factor.

2. **Time interval between two doses of vaccines**: For vaccines that require two - dose inoculations, should the inoculation time of the second dose be delayed so that more people can be inoculated with the first dose first?

3. **Spatial vaccine distribution**: How to optimally distribute the limited vaccine supply among different regions, taking into account factors such as the severity of the epidemic situation and population structure in each region.

### Background and Motivation

With the increasingly close global connections, the risk of infectious disease outbreaks is also increasing. The COVID - 19 pandemic and its global large - scale vaccination have provided valuable lessons, which are helpful for improving future infectious disease models and public health decisions. This review systematically analyzes and classifies the mathematical models used to design the optimal vaccine priority vaccination strategy, especially in the case of initial limited vaccine supply.

### Research Methods

The authors searched the PubMed, Web of Science Core Collection and MathSciNet databases and screened out research articles containing the keywords "age", "model", "COVID - 19", "vaccine", "best" or "optimal", "mathematical" or "computational", "stochastic" or "network". After screening and manual review, 94 articles that used mathematical models to answer at least one vaccine priority vaccination question were finally included.

### Main Findings

1. **Age - stratified vaccine distribution**:
- Most studies (47/70) believe that in order to minimize the mortality rate, the elderly, vulnerable groups and medical staff should be vaccinated first.
- However, some studies (23/70) point out that in some cases, vaccinating young people first can reduce the total number of deaths because young people usually have more social contacts.

2. **Time interval between two doses of vaccines**:
- Most studies (most of the 15 articles) believe that delaying the inoculation time of the second dose of vaccine is beneficial, which can allow more people to be inoculated with the first dose first, thus providing broader initial protection.

3. **Spatial vaccine distribution**:
- Spatial factors are very important in designing the optimal vaccine priority vaccination strategy. The study found that different regions may need different priority vaccination strategies, such as giving priority to regions with high incidence rates or regions with a large elderly population.

### Model Framework and Key Parameters

1. **Model Framework**:
- **Ordinary Differential Equation (ODE) Model**: Most studies use the ODE model to divide the population into different compartments (such as susceptible, infected, recovered). However, these models assume that the population is evenly mixed, which may be inaccurate in practice.
- **Agent - Based Model (ABM)**: A few studies use the ABM to simulate the heterogeneous interactions between individuals, but the computational requirements are high.
- **Partial Differential Equation (PDE) Model**: A few studies use the PDE model, mainly focusing on the spatial aspect of vaccine distribution.

2. **Prediction Time Horizon**:
- The choice of prediction time horizon has an important impact on the vaccine priority vaccination strategy. A shorter prediction time horizon can reduce uncertainty, but may lead to a strategy that is too short - sighted.

3. **Vaccine Eligibility**:
- Most models assume that only the susceptible population can be vaccinated, excluding people with a known history of infection. Some studies have explored the effect of serological testing before vaccination to exclude those already infected.

4. **Vaccination Speed**:
- Public health officials must consider the vaccination speed when deciding who will be vaccinated first. The number of inoculations per day is usually assumed in the model, which will affect the formulation of the optimal strategy.

### Conclusion

This review reveals the impact of different model assumptions and parameters on the vaccine priority vaccination strategy through a systematic analysis of existing mathematical models. Understanding these relationships is helpful for making better public health decisions in future pandemics.