Abstract:Despite the abundance of studies on the control of standing balance, insights about the roles of biomechanics and neural control have been limited. Previous work introduced an analysis combining the direction and orientation of ground reaction forces. The “intersection point” of the lines of actions of these forces exhibited a consistent pattern across healthy, young subjects when computed for different frequency components of the center of pressure signal. To investigate the control strategy of quiet stance, we applied this intersection point analysis to experimental data of 15 healthy, young subjects balancing in tandem stance on a narrow beam and on the ground. Data from the sagittal and frontal planes were analyzed separately. The task was modeled as a double-inverted pendulum controlled by an optimal controller with torque-actuated ankle and hip joints and additive white noise. To test our prediction that the controller that minimized overall joint effort would yield the best fit across the tested conditions and planes of analyses, experimental results were compared to simulation outcomes. The controller that minimized overall effort produced the best fit in both balance conditions and planes of analyses. For some conditions, the relative penalty on the hip and ankle joints varied in a way relevant to the balance condition or to the plane of analysis. These results suggest that unimpaired quiet balance in a challenging environment can be best described by a controller that maintains minimal effort through the adjustment of relative ankle and hip joint torques.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to understand human postural control strategies under different balance conditions, especially how humans maintain balance by adjusting the torques of the ankle and hip joints when standing on a narrow balance beam. The researchers used a new analysis method - intersection point analysis, to quantify the balance control strategy during quiet standing based on the direction and point of application of the ground reaction force. Specifically, the researchers compared the experimental data of 15 healthy young subjects when maintaining tandem stance on the balance beam and on the ground, and compared them with the simulation results of the double - inverted pendulum model to verify whether the minimum - effort controller can best describe the control strategies under these balance conditions. ### Main research questions: 1. **Balance control strategy during quiet standing**: The researchers hope to understand how the human body achieves minimum - effort balance control by adjusting the torques of the ankle and hip joints under different balance conditions. 2. **Application of intersection point analysis**: The researchers use the intersection point analysis method to quantify the balance control strategy through the direction and point of application of the ground reaction force, and explore the applicability of this method under different balance conditions. 3. **Verification of the double - inverted pendulum model**: The researchers verify whether the minimum - effort controller can best describe the balance control strategies observed in the experiment through the simulation results of the double - inverted pendulum model. ### Research background: - Although there are many studies on standing balance control, the understanding of biomechanical and neural control mechanisms is still limited. - Previous studies have mainly focused on the analysis of the center of pressure (COP), but the direction and point of application of the ground reaction force provide more information. - The intersection point analysis method can provide detailed information about the dynamics of human balance control, especially when the human body is in a challenging balance environment. ### Research methods: - **Experimental design**: 15 healthy young subjects maintained tandem stance on the balance beam and on the ground respectively, and the ground reaction force data were recorded. - **Data analysis**: Use the intersection point analysis method to calculate the intersection height in different frequency bandwidths, and compare it with the simulation results of the double - inverted pendulum model. - **Model simulation**: Use the linear quadratic regulator (LQR) as a controller to simulate the human body's balance control strategy by optimizing the cost function of the control input. ### Expected results: - The researchers predict that the minimum - effort controller can best describe the balance control strategies observed in the experiment, whether on the balance beam or on the ground, whether in the sagittal plane or the frontal plane. Through these studies, the author hopes to gain a deeper understanding of the control mechanisms of the human body under challenging balance conditions and provide theoretical support for future balance control research.

Human Foot Force Informs Balance Control Strategies when Standing on a Narrow Beam

Frequency-domain patterns in foot-force line-of-action: an emergent property of standing balance control

Active Control Of Under-Actuated Foot Tilting For Humanoid Push Recovery

Human foot force reveals different balance control strategies between healthy younger and older adults

Human foot force suggests different balance control between younger and older adults

Balance Recovery Analysis With Constraints Of Feet-Ground For Biped Robot

The Contribution of Upper Body Movements to Dynamic Balance Regulation during Challenged Locomotion

Modelling strategies supplemental to foot placement for frontal-plane stability in walking

Joint Role Exploration in Sagittal Balance by Optimizing Feedback Gains

Keep Safe: A Novel Static Balance Control Strategy for Lower Limb Exoskeletons

Center of mass states render multi-joint torques throughout standing balance recovery

A Comparison of Mediolateral Surface and Foot Placement Perturbations on Balance Control and Response Strategies during Walking

Reactive Balance Control in Response to Perturbation in Unilateral Stance: Interaction Effects of Direction, Displacement and Velocity on Compensatory Neuromuscular and Kinematic Responses

Development of control for the ankle joint simulator applied to the problem on vertical posture balance of a human

Rigid soles improve balance in beam walking, but improvements do not persist with bare feet

Frequency spectral characteristics of standing balance with partial foot support

Controlling balance during quiet standing: Proportional and derivative controller generates preceding motor command to body sway position observed in experiments

Examining the joint coordination during dynamic balance learning using vector coding and statistical parametric mapping analyses

Control of human gait stability through foot placement

Effects Of Joint Torque Constraints On Humanoid Robot Balance Recovery In The Presence Of External Disturbance