Abstract:Theory and empirical estimates agree that the ratio of effective size (Ne ) to census size (N) falls roughly in the range 0·1-0·5 for most populations. In a number of marine species, however, genetic estimates of contemporary Ne /N are as much as 5-6 orders of magnitude lower. Although some mechanisms that could produce such tiny Ne /N ratios have been proposed, the subject remains controversial. This issue is important to resolve: if Ne /N can be 10-3 or smaller, marine fish populations that are quite large could be at genetic risk. Based on a recently-improved understanding of factors that influence Ne and Ne /N in species with overlapping generations, this paper evaluates conditions necessary to produce tiny Ne /N ratios in actual populations. These analyses show that although increased longevity, fecundity and variance in reproductive success that increase with age, and increased egg quality with age [the big old fat fecund female fish (BOFFFF) hypothesis] all reduce Ne /N, extreme scenarios are required to reduce Ne /N below about 0·01. Therefore, tiny Ne /N ratios require some version of Hedgecock's 'sweepstakes' hypothesis, whereby only a few families reproduce successfully. Simulations using common genetically-based estimators show that, when true Ne is very large (≥106 ), a substantial fraction of point estimates of Ne /N can be 10-3 or smaller. These results mean that tiny, genetically-based point estimates of Ne /N in large marine populations are expected to be quite common, even when the true Ne /N ratio is 'normal' (∼0·1 or higher). Very large samples of individuals can reduce, but not eliminate, this problem. The simulation results also emphasize the importance of considering deviations from model assumptions (e.g. non-random sampling; weak selection or migration) that may be relatively small (and hence can generally be ignored when the signal is strong) but can lead to substantial biases when the drift signal is weak, as is likely for large marine populations. Empirical studies of this topic need to be able to distinguish between episodes of sweepstakes reproductive success that are ephemeral and lead to chaotic genetic patchiness, and those that are consistent enough across space and time to produce persistent evolutionary consequences.

Effective population size does not explain long-term variation in genome size and transposable element content in animals

Relaxed purifying selection is associated with an accumulation of transposable elements in flies

Strong phylogenetic inertia on genome size and transposable element content among 26 species of flies

Transposons, Genome Size, and Evolutionary Insights in Animals

Size evolution of gigantic genomes suggests stochastic outcomes of transposable element/host silencing interactions

Tiny estimates of the Ne /N ratio in marine fishes: Are they real?

Effective population size does not predict codon usage bias in mammals

Atypical landscape of transposable elements in the large genome of

Multivariate Analysis of Genomic Variables, Effective Population Size, and Mutation Rate

Transposable element diversity and activity patterns in neotropical salamanders

Population size may shape the accumulation of functional mutations following domestication

Trade-offs beget trade-offs: Causal analysis of mammalian population dynamics

Genomic Gigantism is not Associated with Reduced Selection Efficiency in Neotropical Salamanders

Particular sequence characteristics induce bias in the detection of polymorphic transposable element insertions

Genome Size in North American Fireflies: Substantial Variation Likely Driven by Neutral Processes

Orthologous Microsatellites, Transposable Elements, and DNA Deletions Correlate with Generation Time and Body Mass in Neoavian Birds

Transposable Element Expansion and Low-Level Pirna Silencing in Grasshoppers May Cause Genome Gigantism.

Genomic repeat landscape evolution across the teleost fish lineages

The evolution of transposable elements in is governed by purifying selection, while neutral and adaptive processes play a minor role

From Drift to Draft: How Much Do Beneficial Mutations Actually Contribute to Predictions of Ohta’s Slightly Deleterious Model of Molecular Evolution?

Large Variation in the Ratio of Mitochondrial to Nuclear Mutation Rate across Animals: Implications for Genetic Diversity and the Use of Mitochondrial DNA as a Molecular Marker