MaizeCODE reveals bi-directionally expressed enhancers that harbor molecular signatures of maize domestication

Jonathan Cahn,Michael Regulski,Jason Lynn,Evan Ernst,Cristiane de Santis Alves,Srividya Ramakrishnan,Kapeel Chougule,Sharon Wei,Zhenyuan Lu,Xiaosa Xu,Jorg Drenkow,Melissa Kramer,Arun Seetharam,Matthew B. Hufford,W. Richard McCombie,Doreen Ware,David Jackson,Michael C. Schatz,Thomas R. Gingeras,Robert A. Martienssen
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.02.22.581585
2024-02-23
Abstract:Modern maize was domesticated from , with subsequent introgressions from , yielding increased kernel row number, loss of the hard fruit case and dissociation from the cob upon maturity, as well as fewer tillers. Molecular approaches have identified several transcription factors involved in the development of these traits, yet revealed that a complex regulatory network is at play. MaizeCODE deploys ENCODE strategies to catalog regulatory regions in the maize genome, generating histone modification and transcription factor ChIP-seq in parallel with transcriptomics datasets in 5 tissues of 3 inbred lines which span the phenotypic diversity of maize, as well as the teosinte inbred TIL11. Integrated analysis of these datasets resulted in the identification of a comprehensive set of regulatory regions in each inbred, and notably of distal enhancers which were differentiated from gene bodies by their lack of H3K4me1. Many of these distal enhancers expressed non- coding enhancer RNAs bi-directionally, reminiscent of “super enhancers” in animal genomes. We show that pollen grains are the most differentiated tissue at the transcriptomic level, and share features with endosperm that may be related to McClintock’s chromosome breakage- fusion-bridge cycle. Conversely, ears have the least conservation between maize and teosinte, both in gene expression and within regulatory regions, reflecting conspicuous morphological differences selected during domestication. The identification of molecular signatures of domestication in transcriptional regulatory regions provides a framework for directed breeding strategies in maize.
Plant Biology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problems that this paper attempts to solve are: by comprehensively analyzing the cis - regulatory regions in the maize (Zea mays ssp. mays) genome, to reveal the changes in the transcriptional regulatory network during maize domestication, especially the molecular characteristics of distal enhancers and their bidirectionally expressed enhancer RNAs (eRNAs). Specifically, the research aims to: 1. **Identify cis - regulatory regions in maize**: Use the ENCODE strategy to generate histone modification, transcription factor binding site (ChIP - seq), and transcriptome data for multiple tissues and inbred lines, in order to systematically identify the regulatory regions in the maize genome. 2. **Study the impact of domestication on gene regulation**: By comparing the differences between modern maize and its wild ancestor teosinte, explore the conservation and changes in gene expression and regulatory regions during the domestication process. 3. **Reveal the functional characteristics of enhancers**: Especially those distal enhancers that show bidirectionally expressed enhancer RNAs. These enhancers are similar to "super - enhancers" in the animal genome and may play an important role in maize domestication. 4. **Analyze regulatory differences among different tissues and inbred lines**: Through the integrated analysis of data from multiple tissues (such as pollen, young ears, root tips, endosperm, and coleoptile nodes) and multiple inbred lines (including B73, W22, NC350, and the teosinte inbred line TIL11), reveal the regulatory specificity under different tissues and genetic backgrounds. ### Main findings: - **Unique transcriptional profile of pollen**: Pollen shows a unique transcriptional profile in both coding and non - coding regions, especially at the small RNA level, which is significantly different from other tissues. - **Impact of domestication on ear development regulation**: The gene expression and regulatory regions in ear tissues have changed significantly during the domestication process, indicating that ear development is one of the main targets of domestication. - **Bidirectionally expressed enhancer RNAs**: Many distal enhancers have been identified that can bidirectionally express non - coding RNAs, and these enhancers are usually located in open chromatin regions and have high levels of H3K27ac and H3K4me3 modifications. - **Epigenetic changes during domestication**: By comparing modern maize and teosinte, it has been found that the conservation of certain regulatory regions has decreased during the domestication process, especially in ear tissues. Overall, this study provides important clues for understanding the complex gene regulatory network during maize domestication and provides a framework for future targeted breeding strategies.