Matching dynamically varying forces with multi-motor-unit muscle models: A simulation study

Tiina Murtola,Christopher Richards
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.02.13.580042
2024-02-14
Abstract:Human muscles exhibit great versatility, generating forces needed for highly athletic but also fine motor tasks under a variety of contraction conditions. While muscle models used in musculoskeletal modelling can exhibit a similar range of versatility, they often lack a realistic structure with multiple motor units (MUs) and rate-coded control. To investigate how these features affect a muscle’s ability to generate desired force profiles, we have carried out simulations with nine alternative MU pool models for two different cases: 1) a tibialis anterior muscle generating forces matching an isometric trapezoidal force profile, and 2) a generic shoulder muscle matching force profiles from simulated reaching movements while undergoing predetermined length changes. The results suggest that the characteristics of MU pools can impact the pools’ ability to match a given force profile, and that the slowly varying forces of isometric trapezoidal tasks and the relatively fast-changing forces during non-isometric reaching favour different MU pool structures. However, the differences in the performance of different MU pool types are relatively small when considered across all tasks. Furthermore, relatively good force matching results could be obtained with feedforward control utilising a simple mapping from the desired force to a common input signal to all MUs, without a need for feedback corrections. While all MU pool models performed well in the specific conditions tested, our investigation highlights the need to consider the functional characteristics of MU pools. From the perspective of musculoskeletal modelling, rate-coded multi-MU muscles must accomplish a diverse set of dynamic tasks requiring larger force ranges or repeated rapid changes in force. As the range of tasks becomes more realistic, we would expect the properties and construction of MU pools to become increasingly important to achieve good performance.
Physiology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?