Neurobiological slowdown in later life manifests in tempo of popular music

Geoff Luck

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.02.06.579086

2024-02-12

Abstract:Degradation of motor control across the adult lifespan due to neurobiological decay is well-established. Correspondences between the dynamics of motor behaviour and the timing of musical performance are also well-documented. In light of the former, the conspicuous absence of age as a mediating factor in investigation of the latter reveals a remarkable gap in our understanding of creative performance across the life course. To examine effects of ageing on musical timing, physical tempo of almost 2000 songs released by top-tier recording artists over their decades-long careers were annotated via a listening and tapping task. A series of regression analyses revealed i) an age-driven downward trend in performance tempo for all artists, ii) significant between-artist variation across time, and iii) within-artist variation that was independent of broader musical trends. Overall, tempo decreased by almost one and a half standard deviations from artists’ early twenties to their late fifties, a rate of decline comparable to that observed in studies of spontaneous motor tempo. Results are consistent with the slowing-with-age hypothesis, and reveal that, not only is such tempo decline discernible in commercial recordings, the impact of age on tempo is overwhelming for artists most physically connected with their music.

Neuroscience

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper primarily explores the phenomenon of slower rhythm in popular music composition by musicians as they age. The researchers analyzed nearly 2000 songs released by top artists throughout their careers and found a declining trend in performance rhythm for all artists as they grow older. Specifically, from their twenties to their fifties or sixties, the average rhythm decreased by approximately one and a half standard deviations, which aligns with findings on spontaneous movement rhythm. The study also uncovered variations in rhythm changes among artists, with the age effect on rhythm being particularly evident in artists closely associated with music. Furthermore, the study suggests that changes in music rhythm may influence the audience's perception and response to music as rhythm is commonly used to express emotions, styles, and tensions. With this research, the authors have filled an important gap in the study of creative performance throughout the lifespan.