Acute toxicity effects of pesticides on beneficial organisms – Dispelling myths for a more sustainable use of chemicals in agricultural environments

Luis Mata,Rosemary A. Knapp,Robert McDougall,Kathy Overton,Ary A. Hoffmann,Paul A. Umina

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.01.25.577310

2024-01-29

Abstract:Agricultural practitioners, researchers and policymakers are increasingly advocating for integrated pest management (IPM) to reduce pesticide use while preserving crop productivity and profitability. Selective pesticides, putatively designed to act on pests while minimising impacts on off-target organisms, have emerged as one such option – yet evidence of whether these compounds control pests without adversely affecting natural enemies and other beneficial species (henceforth beneficials) remains scarce. At present, the selection of pesticides compatible with IPM often considers a single (or a limited number of) widely distributed beneficial species, without considering undesired effects on co-occurring beneficials. In this study, we conducted standardised laboratory bioassays to assess the acute toxicity effects of 20 chemicals on 15 beneficial species at multiple exposure timepoints, with the specific aims to: (1) identify common and diverging patterns in acute toxicity responses of tested beneficials; (2) determine if the effect of pesticides on beetles, wasps and mites is consistent across species within these groups; and (3) assess the impact of mortality assessment timepoints on International Organisation for Biological Control (IOBC) toxicity classifications. Our work demonstrates that in most cases, chemical toxicities cannot be generalised across a range of beneficial insects and mites providing biological control, a finding that was found even when comparing impacts among closely related species of beetles, wasps and mites. Additionally, we show that toxicity impacts increase with exposure length, pointing to limitations of IOBC protocols. This work challenges the notion that chemical toxicities can be adequately tested on a limited number of ‘representative’ species; instead it highlights the need for careful consideration and testing on a range of regionally and seasonally relevant beneficial species.

Pharmacology and Toxicology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper focuses on the acute toxicity effects of pesticides on beneficial organisms, particularly in the context of achieving more sustainable chemical substance use in agricultural environments. The researchers evaluated the acute toxicity of 20 chemical substances on 15 beneficial species at different exposure time points through laboratory bioassay tests, aiming to identify commonalities and differences in toxic reactions, determine if the effects on beetles, wasps, and mites are consistent within these categories, and assess the time point impact on the International Organization for Biological Control (IOBC) toxicity classification.

The study found that in most cases, the generalization of chemical toxicity does not apply to various insects and mites that provide biological control, even among closely related species. Furthermore, the toxic effects increased with exposure time, indicating limitations of the IOBC protocol. The paper emphasizes the need to test chemical toxicity not only on a few "representative" species but also on a variety of regionally and seasonally relevant beneficial species.

The widespread use of pesticides has negative impacts on non-target species, including natural enemies and other beneficial organisms, creating a contradiction known as the "pesticide paradox" between pesticide control and economic benefits. Integrated Pest Management (IPM) is advocated to reduce pesticide use, which includes the use of selective pesticides designed to minimize the impact on non-target organisms while targeting pests. However, there is limited evidence on whether these selective pesticides can effectively control target pests without adverse effects on various beneficial organisms.

In the study, the authors standardized experiments to assess the acute toxicity response of beneficial insects and arachnids to broad-spectrum and selective pesticides, revealing differences in species' reactions to pesticides and inconsistency in the effects of pesticides on specific insect groups such as beetles, wasps, and mites. They also found that the time point of mortality assessment influenced the IOBC toxicity classification, suggesting the need for improvements in existing toxicity testing methods.

Overall, the paper aims to challenge the current pesticide selection practices that rely on data from a few species' toxicity and calls for careful consideration and testing of more regionally and seasonally relevant beneficial species to promote more sustainable agricultural practices.