Can’t carve air, can’t weave names: Plant species used in Colombian artisan crafts are not equally assessed for vulnerability at the international and national level

Katherine Victoria Hernandez,Federico Andrade-Rivas,Felipe Zapata,Natasha Batista,Anaid Cárdenas-Navarrete,Armando Dávila Arenas,Guido A. Herrera-R,Kelley E. Langhans,Dallas Levey,Andrew Neill,Oliver Nguyen,Natalia Ocampo-Peñuela,Sergio Sánchez Lopez,Alejandra Echeverri

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.01.24.573691

2024-01-26

Abstract:Humanity has maintained cultural connections with our environments for time immemorial. Plants and artisan crafts are a prime example, as craft purpose, skill, design, and species used can vary greatly between communities and the loss of a critical plant species can result in a loss of access to cultural craft practices. To mitigate global biodiversity loss, conservationists are faced with the challenge of assessing species vulnerability to extinction and prioritizing species for conservation funding using information instruments, like the IUCN red list. This process does not necessarily consider a species’ cultural importance. In this paper we sought to address this gap for plant species used in artisan crafts in Colombia. We aim to answer the following: (1) how represented are endemic species in artisan crafts; (2) how threatened are artisan craft species according to (a) international and (b) national vulnerability status? We used the number of species-associated common names as a proxy for cultural awareness. We found that continentally regional species were far more represented in Colombian artisan crafts than national endemics. We also found a strong positive relationship between number of common names and national vulnerability assessment status, but no statistically significant relationship for international vulnerability status. Based on our results, well-known plants used in Colombian artisan crafts are more likely to be assessed nationally than internationally. While the IUCN is thorough in their recommendations, more can be done to prioritize the inclusion of conservation assessments for species based on their contributions to cultural diversity.

Ecology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper mainly discusses the unequal phenomenon of the vulnerability assessment of plant species used in Colombian handicrafts at the international and national levels. The research team consists of 14 scientists and practitioners from different fields who are concerned about the conservation of nature and culture. The core question of the paper is to assess the nativeness and threat level of plant species used in Colombian handicrafts and analyze the relationship between the cultural importance of these species and their international and national vulnerability status.

Specifically, the paper attempts to answer the following questions:
1. How representative are native species in Colombian handicrafts?
2. To what extent are native plant species used in Colombian handicrafts threatened based on (a) international and (b) national vulnerability status?
3. What is the relationship between the (a) international and (b) national vulnerability status of species and their cultural visibility, using the quantity of common names as a proxy indicator of cultural awareness?

Through analysis, the authors found that continental species are more prominent in Colombian handicrafts than nationally endemic ones. They also observed a strong positive correlation between the quantity of common names and national vulnerability assessment status, but no statistically significant relationship with international vulnerability status. Based on these results, the paper points out that well-known plants widely used in Colombian handicrafts are more likely to be evaluated at the national rather than international level. Although the International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN) is quite comprehensive in its recommendations, there is still room for improvement in prioritizing conservation assessments based on species' contributions to cultural diversity.

The paper emphasizes the role of cultural importance in species conservation and calls for greater consideration of this aspect in global biodiversity conservation efforts.