Declining reservoir elevations following a two-decade drought increase water temperatures and non-native fish passage facilitating a downstream invasion

D.E. Eppehimer,C.B. Yackulic,L.A. Bruckerhoff,J. Wang,K.L. Young,K.R. Bestgen,B.A. Mihalevich,J.C. Schmidt

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.01.23.576966

2024-01-25

Abstract:River ecosystems are threatened by interactions among river regulation, non-native species, and climate change. Water use has exceeded supply for two decades in the USA’s Colorado River basin draining its two largest storage reservoirs (Lake Powell and Lake Mead). In 2022, after more than two decades of declining reservoir levels and warming downstream river water temperatures, Lake Powell began releasing water from its lower epilimnion into the Grand Canyon segment of the Colorado River. While managers were concerned about the risk of non-native, predatory smallmouth bass ( ) entrainment and reproduction, they lacked a quantitative tool to understand entrainment rates and population growth potential under different reservoir management strategies. To fill this void, we developed models in spring 2022 that: 1) predicted propagule pressure at different reservoir elevations, and 2) linked reservoir storage/operations, water temperatures, and smallmouth bass population dynamics to forecast population growth rates under different hydrologic and management scenarios. In the summers of 2022 and 2023, smallmouth bass were documented reproducing in the lower Colorado River for the first time. Our models accurately forecasted adult catch of smallmouth bass in 2022 and 2023 and forecasted that reproduction would occur in both years for the first time in the history of this river segment. Above average runoff in 2023 increased reservoir elevations, however the potential for smallmouth bass establishment remains high because of long-term forecasts of reduced reservoir inflows and lake levels significantly below full pool. Maintaining Lake Powell elevations above 1,088 m (3,570 ft) would likely minimize propagule pressure from the reservoir and would likely create downstream conditions that minimize smallmouth bass population growth.

Ecology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper focuses on the invasion of non-native species, smallmouth bass (Micropterus dolomieu), in the Colorado River basin in the United States. Due to a 20-year drought, the water level in reservoirs has dropped, leading to an increase in downstream river water temperature. This has allowed smallmouth bass to enter the river through the release of water from the reservoir, posing a threat to the local ecosystem, particularly federally protected fish species such as humpback chub. In 2022, the water level of Lake Powell reservoir reached a historic low, resulting in increased water temperature and the first reproduction of smallmouth bass in the downstream Colorado River.

In the paper, the researchers developed two models to predict and manage the risk of this invasion: 1) predicting the migration pressure of smallmouth bass under different reservoir water levels; 2) linking reservoir operations, water temperature, and smallmouth bass population dynamics to predict population growth rates under different hydrological and management scenarios. These models successfully predicted the catch of adult smallmouth bass and their reproduction in 2022 and 2023. Despite the temporary increase in water level due to high flows in 2023, the long-term low water level and anticipated decrease in inflow still pose a high risk for the establishment of smallmouth bass populations.

The paper emphasizes the importance of prevention and early intervention in the invasion of non-native species, as they can lead to loss of biodiversity and increased economic costs. The research findings have implications for water resource management and the conservation of native fish species. It is recommended to maintain Lake Powell's water level above a certain height to reduce migration pressure and population growth potential of smallmouth bass, thereby mitigating the threat to downstream ecosystems.