Testing retrogenesis and physiological explanations for tract-wise white matter aging: links to developmental order, fibre calibre, and vascularization

Tyler D. Robinson,Jordan A. Chad,Yutong L. Sun,Paul T. H. Chang,J. Jean Chen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.01.20.576373

2024-08-29

Abstract:To understand the consistently observed spatial distribution of white-matter (WM) aging, developmentally driven theories termed "retrogenesis" have gained traction, positing that the order of WM tract development predicts the order of declines. Regions that develop first are expected to deteriorate the last, i.e. "last-in-first-out". Alternatively, regions which develop most rapidly may also decline most rapidly in aging, or "gains-predict-loss". The validity of such theories remains uncertain, in part due to lack of clarity on the definition of developmental order. Importantly, our recent findings suggest that WM aging is also associated with physiological parameters such as perfusion, which may be linked to fibre metabolic need, which in turn varies with fibre size. Here we address the extent to which the degree of WM aging is determined by development trajectory (i.e. retrogenesis) and/or by physiological state. We obtained microstructural and perfusion measures using data from the Human Connectome Project in Aging (HCP-A), complemented by a meta-analysis involving maps of fibre calibre and macrovascular volume. Our results suggest that (1) while tracts that appear last or finish myelinating first in development display the slowest aging, the pattern of aging is not fully explained by retrogenesis; in fact, time courses of tract emergence and myelination give rise to opposite associations with WM decline; (2) tracts that appear earlier also have higher mean axon calibre and are also associated with lower degrees of WM microstructural aging; (3) such tracts also tend to exhibit relatively sustained CBF with a higher rate of lengthening of the arterial transit times (ATT), suggestive of collateral blood supply. These findings were also sex dependent in a tract-specific manner. Future work will investigate whether these are ultimately influenced by each tract's metabolic demand and the role of macrovascular collateral flow.

Neuroscience

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to understand the mechanism of the spatial distribution change of white matter (WM) during the aging process, especially to explore whether this change is determined by the developmental trajectory (i.e., "retrogenesis") and/or physiological states (such as fibre diameter and vascularization). Specifically, the study aims to test the following hypotheses:

1. **Retrogenesis Theory**:
- **Last - in - first - out (LIFO)**: Whether the white matter tracts that develop early will be the last to degenerate during aging.
- **Gains - predict - loss**: Whether the regions that develop the fastest will also degenerate the fastest during aging.

2. **The Influence of Physiological Factors**:
- **Fibre Calibre**: Whether the fibre diameter of different white matter tracts affects their aging rate.
- **Vascularization and Perfusion**: Whether physiological parameters such as blood perfusion affect the microstructural integrity of white matter tracts.

To verify these hypotheses, the authors used the data set from the Human Connectome Project in Aging (HCP - A), combined diffusion - weighted MRI (dMRI) and perfusion imaging data, analyzed the microstructural integrity and perfusion parameters of 18 major white matter tracts, and evaluated the influence of different developmental and physiological models on white matter aging through multivariate regression models.

### Summary of Main Problems
- **The Validity of the LIFO Theory**: Will the white matter tracts that develop early be the last to degenerate during aging?
- **The Relationship between the Development Rate and the Degeneration Rate**: Will the white matter tracts that develop the fastest also degenerate the fastest during aging?
- **The Role of Physiological Factors**: How do physiological parameters such as fibre diameter, vascularization and perfusion affect the aging of white matter tracts?

Through these analyses, the study hopes to reveal the spatial distribution pattern of white matter aging and the mechanisms behind it, thereby providing new perspectives and evidence for understanding brain aging.