Abstract:The epigenetic landscape was introduced by Conrad Waddington as a metaphor of cellular development. Like a ball rolling down a hillside is channelled through a succession of valleys until it reaches the bottom, cells follow specific trajectories from a pluripotent state to a committed state. Transcription factors (TFs) interacting as a network (the gene regulatory network (GRN)) orchestrate this developmental process within each cell. Here, we quantitatively model the epigenetic landscape using a kind of artificial neural network called the Hopfield network (HN). An HN is composed of nodes (genes/TFs) and weighted undirected edges, resulting in a weight matrix (W) that stores interactions among the nodes over the entire network. We used gene co-expression to compute the edge weights. Through W, we then associate an energy score (E) to each input pattern (pattern of co-expression for a specific developmental stage) such that each pattern has a specific E. We propose that, based on the co-expression values stored in W, HN associates lower E values to stable phenotypic states and higher E to transient states. We validate our model using time course gene-expression data sets representing stages of development across 12 biological processes including differentiation of human embryonic stem cells into specialized cells, differentiation of THP1 monocytes to macrophages during immune response and trans-differentiation of epithelial to mesenchymal cells in cancer. We observe that transient states have higher energy than the stable phenotypic states, yielding an arc-shaped trajectory. This relationship was confirmed by perturbation analysis. HNs offer an attractive framework for quantitative modelling of cell differentiation (as a landscape) from empirical data. Using HNs, we identify genes and TFs that drive cell-fate transitions, and gain insight into the global dynamics of GRNs.

MCLand: A Python program for drawing emerging shapes of Waddington’s epigenetic landscape by Monte Carlo simulations

TMELand: an End-to-end Pipeline for Quantification and Visualization of Waddington’s Epigenetic Landscape Based on Gene Regulatory Network

TMELand: An end-to-end Pipeline for Quantification and Visualization of Waddington's Epigenetic Landscape based on Gene Regulatory Network

Scart: Recognizing Cell Clusters and Constructing Trajectory from Single-Cell Epigenomic Data

3D graphical visualization of the genetic architectures underlying complex traits in multiple environments

Drawing a Waddington landscape to capture dynamic epigenetics

Algorithm for Cartography: Adding Out-domain Knowledge to the Level of Complexity Can Improve the Evolutionary Nature of Multilevel Genotype GIS

McAN: a novel computational algorithm and platform for constructing and visualizing haplotype networks

scAMACE: Model-based approach to the joint analysis of single-cell data on chromatin accessibility, gene expression and methylation

Not just a colourful metaphor: modelling the landscape of cellular development using Hopfield networks

HAPPE: A Tool for Population Haplotype Analysis and Visualization in Editable Excel Tables

Chloroplot: An Online Program for the Versatile Plotting of Organelle Genomes

Detection of colinear blocks and synteny and evolutionary analyses based on utilization of MCScanX

Visualizing the Spatio-Temporal Dynamics of Clonal Evolution with software

Anatomics MLT, an AI tool for large scale quantification of ultrastructural traits

Geometry of Gene Regulatory Dynamics

A geometrical perspective on development

DEMA: a Distance-Bounded Energy-Field Minimization Algorithm to Model and Layout Biomolecular Networks with Quantitative Features

Quantifying Waddington’s Epigenetic Landscape: a Comparison of Single-Cell Potency Measures

MCIBox: A Toolkit for Single-molecule Multi-way Chromatin Interaction Visualization and Micro-Domains Identification

Learning geometric models for developmental dynamics