A new story of four Hexapoda classes: Protura as the sister to all other hexapods

Shiyu Du,Erik Tihelka,Daoyuan Yu,Wan-Jun Chen,Yun Bu,Chenyang Cai,Michael S. Engel,Yun-Xia Luan,Feng Zhang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.01.08.574592

2024-01-08

Abstract:Insects represent the most diverse animal group, yet previous phylogenetic analyses based on the morphological and molecular data have failed to agree on the evolutionary relationships of early insects and their six-legged relatives (together constituting the clade Hexapoda). In particular, the phylogenetic positions of the three early-diverging hexapod groups, the coneheads (Protura), springtails (Collembola), and two-pronged bristletails (Diplura), have been debated for over a century, with alternative topologies implying drastically different scenarios of the evolution of the insect body plan and hexapod terrestrialisation. We addressed this issue by sampling of all hexapod orders, and experimented with a broad range of across-site compositional heterogeneous models designed to tackle ancient divergences. Our analyses support Protura as the earliest-diverging hexapod lineage (Protura-sister) and Collembola as a sister group to the Diplura, a clade we refer to as ‘Antennomusculata’ characterised by the shared possession of internal muscles in the antennal flagellum. The universally recognized ‘Ellipura’ hypothesis is recovered under the site-homogenous LG model. Our cross-validation analysis shows that the CAT-GTR model that recovers Protura-sister fits significantly better than homogenous model. Furthermore, as a very unusual group, Protura as the first diverging lineage of hexapods is also supported by other lines of evidence, such as mitogenomics, comparative embryology, and sperm morphology. The backbone phylogeny of hexapods recovered in this study will facilitate the exploration of the underpinnings of hexapod terrestrialisation and mega-diversity.

Evolutionary Biology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main issue that this paper attempts to address is the phylogenetic relationships among early diverging groups of Hexapoda, particularly the systematic positions of three early diverging hexapod groups—Protura, Collembola, and Diplura. The phylogenetic relationships of these groups have long been controversial, with various hypotheses proposed by different studies, such as the "Ellipura" hypothesis (Protura + Collembola) and the "Nonoculata" hypothesis (Protura + Diplura). By increasing the sample size of these early diverging groups and using multiple analytical methods, the paper aims to resolve these controversies and provide a foundation for understanding the terrestrialization process and body plan evolution of hexapods.