Experimental design impacts the vector competence of Ornithodoros ticks for African swine fever virus: a meta-analysis of published evaluations

Jennifer Bernard,Sara Madeira,Joachim Otte,Fernando Boinas,Marie-Frederique Le Potier,Laurence Vial,Helene Jourdan-Pineau

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2023.11.10.566648

2024-07-03

Abstract:African Swine Fever (ASF) is a highly economically devastating viral disease for swine. Soft ticks of the genus Ornithodoros are involved in its epidemiology, as vectors and natural reservoirs of African Swine Fever Virus (ASFV). This constitutes a significant problem as it is currently challenging to eliminate endophilous soft ticks living in inaccessible, sheltered habitats. The vector competence of Ornithodoros ticks for ASFV has been mainly studied by mimicking natural tick-to-pig transmission pathways through experimental infections in the laboratory. However, experimental designs are anticipated to cause significant influence on the results, owing to inherent technical limitations of the approaches. By reviewing the original research studies dating back to the 1960s on the vector competence of Ornithodoros for ASFV, we estimated the vector competence of 10 tick species in association with 38 viral strains resulting in 51 tick-virus associations. This assessment emphasized the extensive range of protocol designs employed and of vector competence measurements. Those experimental factors have a clear impact on the success of tick infection by ASFV. Our results offer valuable insights into how future trials can be refined by curtailing potential experimental biases. They also call for caution when interpreting conclusions drawn from studies on ASFV vector competence.

Ecology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper primarily explores the interaction between African Swine Fever Virus (ASFV) and the genus Ornithodoros, with a particular focus on the vector competence of soft ticks as a transmission medium for ASFV. Specifically, the paper attempts to address the following key issues:

1. **Impact of Experimental Design on Vector Competence of Soft Ticks**: By reviewing studies on the vector competence of soft ticks for ASFV since the 1960s, the paper evaluates how different experimental designs influence research outcomes. The authors point out that technical limitations in experimental design can significantly affect the success rate of soft tick infection with ASFV.

2. **Assessment of Vector Competence of Soft Ticks for ASFV**: Through the evaluation of 51 tick-virus combinations involving 10 species of soft ticks and 38 virus strains, the paper highlights the differences in experimental methods when measuring the vector competence of soft ticks. These factors have a noticeable impact on the successful infection of ASFV in soft ticks.

3. **Suggestions for Future Experimental Design**: Based on the above analysis, the paper provides recommendations on how to improve future experimental designs to reduce potential biases and obtain more comparable and reliable results. These suggestions aim to enhance the consistency and reliability of research.

In summary, the core purpose of the paper is to assess how experimental design and technical methods influence the vector competence of soft ticks for ASFV and to propose strategies for improving future research.