Abstract:It has been reported that threatening and non-threatening visual stimuli can be distinguished based on the multi-voxel patterns of hemodynamic activity in the human ventral visual stream. Do these findings mean that there may be evolutionarily hardwired mechanisms within early perception, for the fast and automatic detection of threat, and maybe even for the generation of the subjective experience of fear? In this human neuroimaging study, we presented participants (Fear group: N=30; No Fear group: N = 30) with 2700 images of animals that could trigger subjective fear or not as a function of individual’s idiosyncratic “fear profiles” (i.e., fear ratings of animals reported by a given participant). We provide evidence that the ventral visual stream may represent affectively neutral visual features that are statistically associated with fear ratings of participants, without representing the subjective experience of fear itself. More specifically, we show that patterns of hemodynamic activity predictive of a specific “fear profile” can be observed in the ventral visual stream whether a participant reports being afraid of the stimuli or not. Further, we found that the multivariate information synchronization between ventral visual areas and prefrontal regions distinguished participants who reported being subjectively afraid of the stimuli from those who did not. Together, these findings support the view that the subjective experience of fear may depend on the relevant visual information triggering implicit metacognitive mechanisms in the prefrontal cortex.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper aims to explore how the interaction between the visual cortex and the prefrontal cortex supports the subjective experience of fear. Specifically, researchers presented a large number of animal pictures to participants and assessed whether these images could elicit subjective fear based on the individuals' unique "fear profiles" (i.e., the degree of fear towards different animals). The core question of the study is: Does the early stage of visual processing merely represent fear-related but emotionally neutral visual features, or does it also contain information about the subjective experience of fear itself? By comparing the brain activity patterns of participants who reported feeling fear with those who did not, the study seeks to answer this question. Additionally, the research explores the differences in communication between the ventral visual areas and other brain regions (such as the prefrontal cortex) through multivariate information synchronization analysis, to further understand the neural basis of subjective fear experience.

Interaction Between the Prefrontal and Visual Cortices Supports Subjective Fear