Critical reproductive behaviors in Scaled Quail and Northern Bobwhite are affected by thermal variability and mean temperature

William Kirkpatrick,Erin Sauer,Rachel Carroll,Jeremy Cohen,Craig Davis,Samuel Fuhlendorf,Sarah DuRant

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2023.10.20.563339

2024-09-19

Abstract:Animals can respond differently to shifting thermal variability versus thermal averages, both of which are changing due to climate warming. How these thermal variables affect parental care behaviors can reveal the ability of parents to modify their behaviors to meet the competing demands of their offspring’s thermal needs and self-maintenance, which becomes critical in suboptimal thermal conditions. Further, the time frame used to examine the interplay between temperature and behavioral shifts (e.g., seasonal patterns in care vs. drivers of individual care decisions) can provide different information about the plasticity of parental care behavior. We investigated the relationship between thermal means, thermal variability, and incubation behaviors across multiple timescales in Scaled Quail and Northern Bobwhite. Both species decreased off-bout length during periods of high thermal variability, a novel finding among studies of avian parental behavior. Further relationships between thermal endpoints (mean vs. variation) and behavior differed depending on the temporal scale. For instance, total daily time spent off the nest was not influenced by daily average temperature, yet individual off-bout duration increased with increasing average temperature in the two hours prior to the off-bout. These results provide evidence that thermal-behavioral relationships differ across scales and likely represent a bird’s ability to modify their incubation strategy to rapidly respond to the immediate thermal environment (altering individual off-bout length based on temperature) to meet self-maintenance needs while resulting in a similar outcome for their nest (total daily off-bout time). However, longer off-bout durations during high temperature events can come with reproductive costs, sometimes resulting in acute offspring mortality when eggs or chicks experience lethal temperatures.

Animal Behavior and Cognition

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is to explore how the mean and variability of environmental temperature affect the breeding behaviors of Scaled Quail and Northern Bobwhite in North America, especially the off - nest behaviors during the incubation period. The research focuses on the differences in the responses of these birds to temperature changes on different time scales (such as seasonal patterns and individual decision - making drivers), and how these responses affect the ability of parent birds to meet the competing demands between their own maintenance needs and the thermal needs of their offspring.

Specifically, the paper aims to:
1. Explore the effects of average temperature and temperature variability on off - nest behaviors during the incubation period, including changes in off - nest time and frequency.
2. Analyze the manifestations of these behavioral changes on different time scales, such as daily patterns and seasonal changes.
3. Evaluate the impact of these behavioral changes on the balance between parent - bird self - maintenance and offspring care, especially under non - optimal thermal conditions.
4. Investigate whether these behavioral changes can reveal the ability of birds to adapt to the changing thermal environment, especially when facing the challenges brought by climate warming.

Through these analyses, the research hopes to provide information on how birds can quickly respond to the immediate thermal environment by adjusting their incubation strategies, and at the same time explore the potential costs of this strategy for parent birds and their offspring, for example, the increased risk of offspring death due to the prolonged off - nest time during high - temperature events.