Artificial Intelligence in Cardiac Surgery: A Systematic Review

Ralf Martz Sulague,Francis Joshua Beloy,Jillian Reeze Medina,EDWARD DANIEL Daniel MORTALLA,Thea Danielle Cartojano,Sharina Macapagal,Jacques Kpodonu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2023.10.18.23297244

2024-07-05

Abstract:BACKGROUND Artificial intelligence has emerged as a tool to potentially increase efficiency and efficacy of cardiovascular care and improve clinical outcomes. This study aims to provide an overview of applications of artificial intelligence in cardiac surgery. METHODS A systematic literature search on artificial intelligence applications in cardiac surgery from inception to February 2024 was conducted. Articles were then filtered based on the inclusion and exclusion criteria and risk of bias was assessed. Key findings were then summarized RESULTS A total of 81 studies were found that reported on artificial intelligence applications in cardiac surgery. There is a rapid rise in studies since 2020. The most popular machine learning technique was Random Forest (n=48), followed by Support Vector Machine (n=33), Logistic Regression (n=32), and Extreme Gradient Boosting (n=31). Most of the studies were on adult patients, conducted in China, and involved procedures such as valvular surgery (24.7%), heart transplant (9.4%), coronary revascularization (11.8%), congenital heart disease surgery (3.5%), and aortic dissection repair (2.4%). Regarding evaluation outcomes, 35 studies examined the performance, 26 studies examined clinician outcomes, and 20 studies examined patient outcomes. CONCLUSION Artificial intelligence was mainly used to predict complications following cardiac surgeries and improve clinician's decision-making by providing better preoperative risk assessment, stratification, and prognostication. While the application of artificial intelligence in cardiac surgery has greatly progressed in the last decade, further studies need to be done to verify accuracy and ensure safety before use in clinical practice.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper attempts to address the issue of evaluating the application of artificial intelligence (AI) in cardiac surgery to improve the efficiency and effectiveness of cardiovascular care and enhance clinical outcomes. Specifically, the study aims to summarize and analyze the various applications of AI in cardiac surgery, including predicting postoperative complications, assisting clinical decision-making, risk assessment, stratification, and prognosis, through a systematic review of existing literature. The study also explores the performance of these applications, their impact on doctors and patients, and directions for future research.

### Main Issues
1. **Improving the efficiency and effectiveness of cardiovascular care**: By introducing AI technology, improve the efficiency and effectiveness of cardiac surgery, reduce medical errors, and enhance patient safety.
2. **Enhancing clinical outcomes**: Improve patient clinical outcomes and reduce the risk of postoperative complications through AI technology's prediction and decision support.
3. **Summarizing existing applications**: Systematically review and summarize the existing literature on AI applications in cardiac surgery, including different machine learning techniques and their application areas.
4. **Evaluating performance and impact**: Assess the performance of these AI applications in actual clinical settings and their specific impact on doctors and patients.
5. **Future research directions**: Propose future research directions to ensure the application of AI technology in cardiac surgery is more accurate and safe.

### Research Methods
- **Literature search**: Conduct a systematic literature search using multiple databases to select studies that meet the inclusion criteria.
- **Data extraction**: Extract key information from the included studies, including study design, sample size, AI application characteristics, and main results.
- **Quality assessment**: Use the Joanna Briggs Institute (JBI) critical appraisal tools to assess the quality of the included studies.

### Main Findings
- **Increase in research quantity**: Since 2020, the number of studies on the application of AI in cardiac surgery has significantly increased.
- **Common machine learning techniques**: Random Forest, Support Vector Machine, Logistic Regression, and Extreme Gradient Boosting are the most commonly used machine learning techniques.
- **Application areas**: Most studies focus on adult patients, involving valve surgery, heart transplantation, coronary artery bypass grafting, etc.
- **Main applications**: AI is mainly used to predict postoperative complications, provide preoperative risk assessment and stratification, and prognosis prediction.
- **Performance evaluation**: 35 studies evaluated the performance of AI applications, 26 studies assessed doctors' user experience, and 20 studies evaluated patient outcomes.

### Conclusion
- **Main uses**: AI is mainly used to predict complications after cardiac surgery, improving doctors' decision-making by providing better preoperative risk assessment and stratification.
- **Future directions**: Although significant progress has been made in the application of AI in cardiac surgery, further research is needed to verify its accuracy and ensure safety, especially in clinical practice.

The paper comprehensively summarizes the current status of AI applications in cardiac surgery through a systematic review, providing important references for future research and clinical applications.