Re-evaluation and revision of the Eating Habits Questionnaire

Dávid Simon,Nikolett Bogár,Szilvia Dukay-Szabó,Ferenc Túry

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2023.10.06.23296639

2024-05-10

Abstract:The Eating Habits Questionnaire (EHQ) is a key tool in evaluating orthorexia nervosa, but its evaluation process has witnessed considerable variation, with one item notably excluded from the last phase of its development. This study undertakes a thorough re-evaluation of the English version of the EHQ, focusing on its original 35 items, within two diverse populations where English serves predominantly as a second language. Through an online survey involving 163 female models and 243 non-models, participants completed the EHQ along with the Eating Disorder Inventory (EDI) and SCOFF questionnaire. Using Confirmatory Factor Analysis, we scrutinised the factorial validity of EHQ subscales, eliminating items that did not align with the factor structure. After eliminating 17 items from the original 35-item questionnaire, the fit of the model for EHQ was acceptable. Cronbach’s alpha values indicated acceptable reliability. The EHQ problem subscale showed significant positive correlations with all EDI subscales, while all EHQ subscales demonstrated significant positive correlations with the EDI drive for thinness subscale. Comparison of the groups based on the SCOFF threshold revealed positive and significant differences across all subscales. The study examined the impact of replacing an item in the EHQ-21 during its development process, finding that it potentially influenced the resulting factor structure. A new version of EHQ (EHQ-18) was introduced supported by the analysis of the factorial and convergent validity, as well as the reliability. Furthermore, the findings suggest a potential discriminant validity of EHQ-18 in a diverse population, mostly speaking English as a second language.

Psychiatry and Clinical Psychology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper focuses on the reevaluation and revision of the Eating Habits Questionnaire (EHQ), a tool used to assess orthorexia nervosa. During the development of the questionnaire, one item was excluded, resulting in the emergence of different versions. The study collected data from 163 female models and 243 non-models through an online survey, in which participants completed the EHQ, Eating Disorder Inventory (EDI), and SCOFF questionnaire.

Confirmatory factor analysis (CFA) was used in the paper to examine the factor validity of the EHQ subscales and exclude items that were inconsistent with the factor structure. After selection, 17 items were removed from the original 35 items, resulting in a new version with 18 items (EHQ-18). The model fit well, and the Cronbach's alpha values indicated acceptable reliability. The study found that the subscales of EHQ-18 were significantly positively correlated with all subscales of EDI, and all EHQ subscales were also significantly positively correlated with the Drive for Thinness subscale of EDI. Comparing the two groups based on SCOFF threshold revealed positive and significant differences in all subscales.

In addition, the study explored the replacement of one item during the EHQ-21 development process, which could potentially affect the factor structure. It suggested that EHQ-18 had potential discriminant validity, especially in a diverse population with English as a second language. Although the sample was mainly limited to young females and non-native English speakers, the results indicated the effectiveness of EHQ-18. However, the study also pointed out limitations in sample selection and the possibility of overfitting, and further verification of these findings in a broader population was recommended.