Stability metrics are robust across data qualities but sensitive to community size.

Duncan A O'Brien,Christopher F Clements

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2023.09.25.559298

2024-10-07

Abstract:Modern biodiversity monitoring is generating increasingly multidimensional representations of wildlife populations and ecosystems. It is therefore appealing for conservation and environmental governance to combine that information into single measure of ecosystem or population health. Stability is a desirable feature of ecosystems that supports this aim. It is primarily measured through its resistance, resilience (a.k.a recovery), and variability. The Jacobian matrix is a common characteristic used to identify the resistance and resilience of deterministic mathematical systems and whilst historically it has been challenging to estimate from empirical data, recent work has proposed a suite of metrics capable of reconstructing it for a real-world community using time series data. Here we assess the robustness of three Jacobian metrics and two variability estimating stability metrics (multivariate index of variability and Fisher information) to varying time series lengths and data qualities based on that seen in real-world wildlife time series. We generate data using multispecies Lotka Volterra equations and simulate stressed and unstressed communities of varying species number. These data were then corrupted through the introduction of sampling error (to mimic varying search efforts) and truncating time series (to match the typical time series lengths reported in global biodiversity datasets such as the Living Planet Index and BIOTIME). The robustness of all stability metrics improved with time series length and sampling error in the anticipated manner. However, community size (number of species) dramatically altered metric capability, with larger communities decreasing the reliability of stability metric trends. Overall, stability metrics behave predictably across realistic data corruptions. Generic stability estimation is therefore possible from abundance time series alone, and we suggest that, given the increasing availability of multivariate community data, focussing on Jacobian estimates is a promising avenue of research. However, we also show it is prudent to apply ecological knowledge when selecting which species to contribute.

Ecology