Overlapping Neural Correlates Underpin Theory of Mind and Semantic Cognition: Evidence from a Meta-Analysis of 344 Functional Neuroimaging Studies

Eva Balgova,Veronica Diveica,Rebecca L. Jackson,Richard J. Binney

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2023.08.16.553506

2024-03-28

Abstract:Key unanswered questions for cognitive neuroscience include whether social cognition is underpinned by specialised brain regions and to what extent it simultaneously depends on more domain-general systems. Until we glean a better understanding of the full set of contributions made by various systems, theories of social cognition will remain fundamentally limited. In the present study, we evaluate a recent proposal that semantic cognition plays a crucial role in supporting social cognition. While previous brain-based investigations have focused on dissociating these two systems, our primary aim was to assess the degree to which the neural correlates are overlapping, particularly within two key regions, the anterior temporal lobe (ATL) and the temporoparietal junction (TPJ). We focus on activation associated with theory of mind (ToM) and adopt a meta-analytic activation likelihood approach to synthesise a large set of functional neuroimaging studies and compare their results with studies of semantic cognition. As a key consideration, we sought to account for methodological differences across the two sets of studies, including the fact that ToM studies tend to use nonverbal stimuli while the semantics literature is dominated by language-based tasks. Overall, we observed consistent overlap between the two sets of brain regions, especially in the ATL and TPJ. This supports the claim that tasks involving ToM draw upon more general semantic retrieval processes. We also identified activation specific to ToM in the right TPJ, bilateral anterior mPFC, and right precuneus. This is consistent with the view that, nested amongst more domain-general systems, there is specialised circuitry that is tuned to social processes.

Neuroscience

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper attempts to address the extent of overlap between Theory of Mind (ToM) and Semantic Cognition in terms of their neural basis. Specifically, the study focuses on the following aspects:

1. **Overlap in Neural Basis**: The study evaluates the critical role of semantic cognition in supporting social cognition and explores whether there is an overlap in neural correlates of both in two key brain regions: the Anterior Temporal Lobe (ATL) and the Temporoparietal Junction (TPJ).

2. **Role of Specific Brain Regions**: The study also identifies activation areas associated solely with ToM, such as the right TPJ, bilateral Anterior Medial Prefrontal Cortex (mPFC), and the right Precuneus.

3. **Impact of Methodological Differences**: To ensure the reliability of the results, the researchers considered methodological differences between the two sets of studies, including the tendency of ToM studies to use non-verbal stimuli, while semantic studies primarily rely on language tasks. By controlling for these differences, the study aims to reveal the true overlap and specificity between the two systems.

In summary, the core objective of this paper is to systematically compare the large-scale neural networks of ToM and semantic cognition through meta-analysis, with a particular focus on the ATL and TPJ regions, to better understand their relationship in terms of neural mechanisms.