Artificial selection improves pollutant degradation by bacterial communities

Flor Ines Arias-Sanchez,Bjorn Vessman,Alice Haym,Geraldine Alberti,Sara Mitri

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2023.07.27.550627

2024-07-02

Abstract:Artificial selection is a promising way to improve microbial community functions, but previous experiments have only shown moderate success. Here, we experimentally evaluate a new method that was inspired by genetic algorithms to artificially select small bacterial communities of known species composition based on their degradation of an industrial pollutant. Starting from 29 randomly generated four-species communities, we repeatedly grew communities for four days, selected the 10 best-degrading communities, and rearranged them into 29 new communities composed of four species of equal ratios whose species compositions resembled those of the most successful communities from the previous round. The best community after 18 such rounds of selection degraded the pollutant better than the best community in the first round. It featured member species that degrade well, species that degrade badly alone but improve community degradation, and free-rider species that did not contribute to community degradation. Most species in the evolved communities did not differ significantly from their ancestors in their phenotype, suggesting that genetic evolution plays a small role at this time scale. These experiments show that artificial selection on microbial communities can work in principle, and inform on how to improve future experiments.

Evolutionary Biology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper primarily explores how to improve the degradation ability of bacterial communities for industrial pollutants—Metal Working Fluids (MWFs)—through artificial selection. The research team designed a new method called "disassembly selection," inspired by genetic algorithms, aimed at automatically exploring the space of different species combinations to find the optimal community configuration.

Specifically, the researchers randomly generated 29 initial communities, each composed of 4 species out of 11 bacteria capable of degrading MWFs. In each round of experiments, these communities were cultured for 4 days and then scored based on their degradation ability. The top 10 communities with the best degradation performance were selected, their member species were separated, and then recombined into 29 new communities. This selection process was repeated for 18 rounds.

The results showed that after 18 rounds of selection, the best-performing community achieved a degradation rate of 75.1% for MWFs, significantly higher than the initial communities (with an average degradation rate of 44.4%). Nevertheless, this improvement was still relatively modest. Additionally, the study found that certain species' roles in the community were not limited to directly degrading pollutants but also included promoting the growth of other species or acting as "freeriders," which do not directly contribute to community function but still benefit from it.

In summary, the problem this paper attempts to address is how to optimize the function of bacterial communities through artificial selection, particularly to enhance their degradation efficiency for specific industrial pollutants. The research results indicate that this method can achieve the goal to a certain extent but also highlight existing limitations and potential directions for future improvements.