Abstract:Recent models of movement generation in motor cortex have sought to explain neural activity not as a function of movement parameters, known as representational models, but as a dynamical system acting at the level of the population. Despite evidence supporting this framework, the evaluation of representational models and their integration with dynamical systems is incomplete in the literature. Using a representational velocity-tuning based simulation of center-out reaching, we show that incorporating variable latency offsets between neural activity and kinematics is sufficient to generate rotational dynamics at the level of neural populations, a phenomenon observed in motor cortex. However, we developed a covariance-matched permutation test (CMPT) that reassigns neural data between task conditions independently for each neuron while maintaining overall neuron-to-neuron relationships, revealing that rotations based on the representational model did not uniquely depend on the underlying condition structure. In contrast, rotations based on either a dynamical model or motor cortex data depend on this relationship, providing evidence that the dynamical model more readily explains motor cortex activity. Importantly, implementing a recurrent neural network we demonstrate that both representational tuning properties and rotational dynamics emerge, providing evidence that a dynamical system can reproduce previous findings of representational tuning. Finally, using motor cortex data in combination with the CMPT, we show that results based on small numbers of neurons or conditions should be interpreted cautiously, potentially informing future experimental design. Together, our findings reinforce the view that representational models lack the explanatory power to describe complex aspects of single neuron and population level activity.

Motor cortex latent dynamics encode spatial and temporal arm movement parameters independently

Motor Cortex Latent Dynamics Encode Spatial and Temporal Arm Movement Parameters Independently

Different population dynamics in the supplementary motor area and motor cortex during reaching

Spatial Evolution of Information Dynamics in the Primary Motor Cortex During Reach

Neural Synergies for Controlling Reach and Grasp Movement in Macaques.

Neural Geometry from Mixed Sensorimotor Selectivity for Predictive Sensorimotor Control

Propagating Motor Cortical Dynamics Facilitate Movement Initiation.

Neural Population Dynamics during Reaching Are Better Explained by a Dynamical System than Representational Tuning

Internal Dynamics Interact with Proprioceptive Feedback During Movement Execution in an RNN Model of Motor Cortex

When and why does motor preparation arise in recurrent neural network models of motor control?

Prediction of Switching Time Between Movement Preparation and Execution by Neural Activity in Monkey Premotor Cortex

Neural dynamics hierarchy in motor cortex and striatum across naturalistic behaviors

Neuro-musculoskeletal modeling reveals muscle-level neural dynamics of adaptive learning in sensorimotor cortex

Global motor dynamics - invariant neural representations of motor behavior in distributed brain-wide recordings

The natural variability of a dexterous motor skill is stably encoded in the cortex of freely behaving mice

Emergence of Coordinated Neural Dynamics Underlies Neuroprosthetic Learning and Skillful Control

Learning and Encoding Motor Primitives for Limb Actions in a Brain-Like Computation Approach.

Task-driven neural network models predict neural dynamics of proprioception

Propagating Patterns of Activity Across Motor Cortex Facilitate Movement Initiation