Abstract:ABSTRACT Modifications on viral RNAs (vRNAs), either genomic RNAs or RNA transcripts, have complex effects on the viral life cycle and cellular responses to viral infection. The advent of Oxford Nanopore Technologies Direct RNA Sequencing provides a new strategy for studying RNA modifications. To this end, multiple computational tools have been developed, but a systemic evaluation of their performance in mapping vRNA modifications is lacking. Here, 10 computational tools were tested using the Sindbis virus (SINV) RNAs isolated from infected mammalian (BHK-21) or mosquito (C6/36) cells, with in vitro -transcribed RNAs serving as modification-free control. Three single-mode approaches were shown to be inapplicable in the viral context, and three out of seven comparative methods required cutoff adjustments to reduce false-positive predictions. Utilizing optimized cutoffs, an integrated analysis of comparative tools suggested that the intersected predictions of Tombo_com and xPore were significantly enriched compared with the background. Consequently, a pipeline integrating Tombo_com and xPore was proposed for vRNA modification detection; the performance of which was supported by N 6 -methyladenosine prediction in severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 RNAs using publicly available data. When applied to SINV RNAs, this pipeline revealed more intensive modifications in subgenomic RNAs than in genomic RNAs. Modified uridines were frequently identified, exhibiting substantive overlapping between vRNAs generated in different cell lines. On the other hand, the interpretation of other modifications remained unclear, underlining the limitations of the current computational tools despite their notable potential. IMPORTANCE Computational approaches utilizing Oxford Nanopore Technologies Direct RNA Sequencing data were almost exclusively designed to map eukaryotic epitranscriptomes. Therefore, extra caution must be exercised when using these tools to detect vRNA modifications, as in most cases, vRNA modification profiles should be regarded as unknown epitranscriptomes without prior knowledge. Here, we comprehensively evaluated the performance of 10 computational tools in detecting vRNA modification sites. All tested single-mode methods failed to differentiate native and in vitro- transcribed samples. Using optimized cutoff values, seven tested comparative tools generated very different predictions. An integrated analysis showed significant enrichment of Tombo_com and xPore predictions against the background. A pipeline for vRNA modification detection was proposed accordingly and applied to Sindbis virus RNAs. In conclusion, our study underscores the need for the careful application of computational tools to analyze viral epitranscriptomics. It also offers insights into alphaviral RNA modifications, although further validation is required.

Multicellular, IVT-derived, unmodified human transcriptome for nanopore direct RNA analysis

A comprehensive survey of RNA modifications in a human transcriptome

NanoTrans: an integrated computational framework for comprehensive transcriptome analysis with Nanopore direct RNA sequencing

Direct RNA sequencing (RNA004) allows for improved transcriptome assessment and near real-time tracking of methylation for medical applications

Nanopore Guided Annotation of Transcriptome Architectures

DirectRMDB: a database of post-transcriptional RNA modifications unveiled from direct RNA sequencing technology

Advances in nanopore direct RNA sequencing

Transfer learning enables identification of multiple types of RNA modifications using nanopore direct RNA sequencing

Analysis of bacterial transcriptome and epitranscriptome using nanopore direct RNA sequencing

Comprehensive identification of diverse ribosomal RNA modifications by targeted nanopore direct RNA sequencing and JACUSA2

Comparative analysis of 43 distinct RNA modifications by nanopore tRNA sequencing

DRUMMER-rapid detection of RNA modifications through comparative nanopore sequencing

Detection and Quantification of 5moU RNA Modification from Direct RNA Sequencing Data

Single-Molecule Direct RNA Sequencing Reveals the Shaping of Epitranscriptome Across Multiple Species

Nanopore-based native RNA sequencing of human transcriptomes reveals the complexity of mRNA modifications and crosstalk between RNA regulatory features

Attomole quantification and global profile of RNA modifications: Epitranscriptome of human neural stem cells

Utilization of nanopore direct RNA sequencing to analyze viral RNA modifications

Identification of differential RNA modifications from nanopore direct RNA sequencing with xPore

Isoform-level profiling of m6A epitranscriptomic signatures in human brain

Nanopore native RNA sequencing of a human poly(A) transcriptome

NERD-seq: a novel approach of Nanopore direct RNA sequencing that expands representation of non-coding RNAs