Abstract:Throughout the evolutionary tree, there are gains and losses of morphological features, physiological processes, and behavioral patterns. Losses are perhaps nowhere so prominent as for subterranean organisms, which typically show reductions or losses of eyes and pigment. These losses seem easy to explain without recourse to natural selection. Its most modern form is the accumulation of selectively neutral, structurally reducing mutations. Selectionist explanations include direct selection, often involving metabolic efficiency in resource poor subterranean environments, and pleiotropy, where genes affecting eyes and pigment have other effects, such as increasing extra-optic sensory structures. This dichotomy echoes the debate in evolutionary biology in general about the sufficiency of natural selection as an explanation of evolution, e.g., Kimura's neutral mutation theory. Tests of the two hypotheses have largely been one-sided, with data supporting that one or the other processes is occurring. While these tests have utilized a variety of subterranean organisms, the Mexican cavefish, Astyanax mexicanus , which has eyed extant ancestral-like surface fish conspecifics, is easily bred in the lab, and whose whole genome has been sequenced, is the favored experimental organism. However, with few exceptions, tests for selection versus neutral mutations contain limitations or flaws. Notably, these tests are often one sided, testing for the presence of one or the other process. In fact, it is most likely that both processes occur and make a significant contribution to the two most studied traits in cave evolution: eye and pigment reduction. Furthermore, narrow focus on neutral mutation hypothesis versus selection to explain cave-evolved traits often fails, at least in the simplest forms of these hypotheses, to account for aspects that are likely essential for understanding cave evolution: migration or epigenetic effects. Further, epigenetic effects and phenotypic plasticity have been demonstrated to play an important role in cave evolution in recent studies. Phenotypic plasticity does not by itself result in genetic change of course, but plasticity can reveal cryptic genetic variation which then selection can act on. These processes may result in a radical change in our thinking about evolution of subterranean life, especially the speed with which it may occur. Thus, perhaps it is better to ask what role the interaction of genes and environment plays, in addition to natural selection and neutral mutation.

Highly dynamic evolution of the chemosensory system driven by gene gain and loss across subterranean beetles

Highly dynamic evolution of the chemosensory system driven by gene gain and loss across subterranean beetles

Functional olfactory evolution in <i>Drosophila</i> <i>suzukii</i> and the subgenus <i>Sophophora</i>

Evolution of chemosensory tissues and cells across ecologically diverse Drosophilids

Genomic content of chemosensory receptors in two sister blister beetles facilitates characterization of chemosensory evolution

Few chemoreceptor genes in the ambrosia beetle Trypodendron lineatum may reflect its specialized ecology

The genomic and cellular basis of biosynthetic innovation in rove beetles

Gene Expression and Functional Analyses of Odorant Receptors in Small Hive Beetles (aethina Tumida)

Evolutionary Dynamics of Lineage-Specific Class-A GPCR Subsets Reveal Widespread Chemosensory Roles and Adaptations in Lophotrochozoa

The evolution of chemoreception in squamate reptiles: a phylogenetic approach

Evolution of a pest: towards the complete neuroethology of Drosophila suzukii and the subgenus Sophophora

Evolutionary History of Chemosensory-Related Gene Families across the Arthropoda

Conserved orthology in termite chemosensory gene families

Candidate membrane protein gene families related to chemoreception in a wood-boring beetle, Pharsalia antennata Gahan (Coleoptera: Cerambycidae)

Diversity and evolution of the vertebrate chemoreceptor gene repertoire

Functional and evolutionary insights into chemosensation and specialized herbivory from the genome of the red milkweed beetle, Tetraopes tetrophthalmus (Cerambycidae: Lamiinae)

Divergence of chemosensing during the early stages of speciation

Ancestral complexity and constrained diversification of the ant olfactory system

Cave beetle lineages gained genes before going down under: An example of repeated genomic exaptation?

Natural selection versus neutral mutation in the evolution of subterranean life: A false dichotomy?

Chemosensory signal transduction in Caenorhabditis elegans