Abstract:Many organisms have sex chromosomes with large non-recombining regions that expand in a stepwise manner, although the underlying reasons remain poorly understood. Recently, we proposed that recombination suppression may evolve in sex chromosomes simply because of the presence of recessive deleterious mutations within genomes. Specifically, we demonstrated that chromosomal inversions suppressing recombination and carrying by chance fewer deleterious mutations than average have a selective advantage. In addition, we showed that the permanent heterozygosity of Y-like sex chromosomes facilitates the fixation of these less-loaded inversions by a sheltering effect, i.e., by preventing the expression of recessive deleterious mutations in a homozygous state when they increase in frequency. In contrast, similar less-loaded inversions in autosomes suffer from a disadvantage in the homozygous state as their frequency increases, preventing their fixation. However, the methodology and significance of our previous study have been questioned. Here, we present new analyses that further reinforce our original claims, demonstrating that the lower-load advantage and the sheltering effect can explain the fixation of inversions on sex chromosomes over a broad range of parameter values. We show that these mechanisms promote the fixation of inversions on Y-like chromosomes at rates exceeding those expected under drift alone. We used, as a control, autosomes with a similar population size as the Y chromosome, which, we argue, provides the appropriate neutral control for the sheltering effect. We also address criticisms regarding our focus on inversions surviving the first 20 generations in a figure of our previous study, and show that these criticisms stemmed from a misunderstanding of what this figure was intended to illustrate. Including all inversions, even those that went extinct within 20 generations, does not alter our conclusions. Overall, the present study offers new support for our theory based on the combination of lower-load advantage and sheltering effect, and addresses the questions about its significance and range of applicability.

Chromosomal inversions and the demography of speciation in and

Chromosome inversions, local adaptation and speciation

Coupling of twelve putative chromosomal inversions maintains a strong barrier to gene flow between snail ecotypes

Chromosomal inversions and their impact on insect evolution

Young Inversion with Multiple Linked QTLs under Selection in a Hybrid Zone.

Natural selection and the distribution of chromosomal inversion lengths

Unravelling Inversions: Technological Advances, Challenges, and Potential Impact on Crop Breeding

Locally adaptive inversions in structured populations

The influence of chromosomal inversions on genetic variation and clinal patterns in genomic data of Drosophila melanogaster

Chromosomal rearrangements preserve adaptive divergence in ecological speciation

Divergence and gene flow history at two large chromosomal inversions underlying ecotype differentiation in the long‐snouted seahorse

Introgression dynamics of sex-linked chromosomal inversions shape the Malawi cichlid adaptive radiation

Inversions Can Accumulate Balanced Sexual Antagonism: Evidence from Simulations and Drosophila Experiments

Inference of chromosomal inversion dynamics from Pool-Seq data in natural and laboratory populations of Drosophila melanogaster

Intercontinental karyotype–environment parallelism supports a role for a chromosomal inversion in local adaptation in a seaweed fly

Analysis of meiotic recombination in shows heterozygous inversions do not cause an interchromosomal effect

Large inversions in Lake Malawi cichlids are associated with habitat preference, lineage, and sex determination

How repeats rearrange chromosomes in deer mice

Deleterious mutations can contribute to the evolution of recombination suppression between sex chromosomes

The evolutionary dynamics of locally adaptive chromosome inversions in Mimulus guttatus

Increased evolutionary rate in the Z-chromosome of butterflies and implications for speciation