The angry genie: one man's walk through the nuclear age [Books]

J. Poston

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/MSPEC.2000.819923

IF: 3.578

2000-02-01

IEEE Spectrum

Abstract:must admit a very penonal interest in reading and reviewing this little book. I I worked for Karl Z. Morgan at Oak Ridge Laboratory in Tennessee for nearly nine years and subsequently served on the faculty with h im a t t he Georgia Institute of Technology, Atlanta. He seeme d to me the epitome of the Southern gentleman-very considerate of others, extremely well-mannered, and above all very reluctant to talk openly about his accomplishments, including his earlier career. So The Angry Genie gave me an opportunity to learn more about him. Morgan's long and distiriguished career in health physics began in the secrecy of World War II . It ended decades later with him standing alone, an outspoken critic of the profession he helped found. In 1942, he was teaching physics and studying cosmic radiation at a small college in North Carolina when he was asked to Chicago to meet Arthur Holly Compton. A Nnhrl l a u m t e , Compton had been put in charge of the activities at the University of Chicago associated with the Manhattan Engineering District (the U.S. effort to build a nuclear reactor and then the first nuclear weapon). He a n d his associate Robert S. Stone, recognizing they might After the war, the Clinton Laboratory was renamed Oak Ridge National Laboratory, and its Health Physics Division continued to grow under Morgan's astute leadership. In particular, it served as the training center for young scientists and engineers entering the profession and as an outstanding national and international r e ~ search center in health physics, Morgan has been called the "father of health physics," and this title seems justified. Besides leading the Health Physics Division to orominence. he was one of the on the so-called military-industry complex and the secrecy that cloaked its activities during the Cold War. The most famous case he was involved in was Silkwood v e r ~ sus Ken McCee, which involved a woman who died under suspicious circumstances while publicizing what she considered careless or even criminal practices at a Kerr McCee factory (The case later was made the basis of a movie that starred Meryl Streep in the Silkwood role.) Later in Morgan's career, his testimony in such litigation was heavily discounted in a ruling by a Federal judge, and his role in such legal actions essentially ceased. It seemed that a k r this, he returned to his roots, spending much of his time in North Carolina. He died on 8 June last year. While I did not always agree with Morgan's positions on techni~ cal issues, I never questioned his dedication to doing what was right as he saw it. He was a sincere Christian of the highest moral principles who originally was headed for the ministry For both better and worre, a certain oreachiness was oart of his first to include environmental studies in its research portfoli-the Ecological Section he established was eventually to become the large Environmental Sciences Division. H e was the founding president of the Health Physics Society and editor-in-chief of the journal Health Physics. He also was the first president of the International Radiapproach to the world. The book is not a complete autobiography, containing as it does only selected descriptions of Morgan's career. Moreover, a coauthor-the lawyer Ken M. Petersonwrote two (unspecified) chapters, leaving some ambiguity as to whose voice is speakinn at any given time. The main bodv of