Pictorial balance is a bottom-up neuro-aesthetic property mediating attention and eye movements. A primitive visual operating system explains the property of balance and a primary visual way of organizing the world.

David M Corwin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2020.05.26.104687

2024-10-23

Abstract:Pictorial balance has been used to explain why some paintings evoke feelings of unity and harmony. The present study shows how the low-level visual system calculates balance in pictures, why it evokes these feelings of unity and harmony and created the earlier perception of balance, and its evolutionary importance in visualizing the world of moving organisms. The concept of pictorial balance as a center of mass effect, i.e. the feeling that somehow a person on the left seems to be balanced by a tree on the right, originated at the beginning of the 20th century. It had never been mentioned in art commentary of the previous 500 years, and yet has become a widely assumed but an unsubstantiated explanation of why some paintings evoke feelings of unity and harmony. Despite this lack of historical documentation, the perception of pictorial balance exists. This study starts with an elusive pictorial effect known to painters evoking these feelings of harmony and unity. In such pictures the image seems to be perceived as a whole without the need to fixate on individually depicted objects. First described by a 17th century critic Roger de Piles and subsequently by a few renowned artists, the author thought that this response was because the picture was in a state of perfect balance. Computer modeling found that such a picture must have bilateral luminance symmetry with a lighter lower half by ~1.07. A study was conducted in which the identical picture seen sequentially in slightly different frames could seem different to observers because of the change in balance created by the frames. The results indicate that the extent to which the picture pairs were seen as different correlated with a proposed method of calculating balance. This method could be understood as a primitive visual operating system identifying moving organisms as luminous objects and evaluating them in terms of balance. Balanced is determined solely by luminosity as seen in peripheral vision. The more balanced the picture, the more it will be seen as a whole, an object evoking feelings of unity and harmony. It is proposed that in the evolution of vision this luminance pathway using balance was the initial way for organisms to organize the world from luminance and movement.

Neuroscience