Abstract:Asynchronous and parallel implementation of standard reinforcement learning (RL) algorithms is a key enabler of the tremendous success of modern RL. Among many asynchronous RL algorithms, arguably the most popular and effective one is the asynchronous advantage actor-critic (A3C) algorithm. Although A3C is becoming the workhorse of RL, its theoretical properties are still not well-understood, including its non-asymptotic analysis and the performance gain of parallelism (a.k.a. linear speedup). This paper revisits the A3C algorithm and establishes its non-asymptotic convergence guarantees. Under both i.i.d. and Markovian sampling, we establish the local convergence guarantee for A3C in the general policy approximation case and the global convergence guarantee in softmax policy parameterization. Under i.i.d. sampling, A3C obtains sample complexity of $\mathcal{O}(\epsilon^{-2.5}/N)$ per worker to achieve $\epsilon$ accuracy, where $N$ is the number of workers. Compared to the best-known sample complexity of $\mathcal{O}(\epsilon^{-2.5})$ for two-timescale AC, A3C achieves \emph{linear speedup}, which justifies the advantage of parallelism and asynchrony in AC algorithms theoretically for the first time. Numerical tests on synthetic environment, OpenAI Gym environments and Atari games have been provided to verify our theoretical analysis.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper attempts to solve the following problems:
1. **Convergence analysis of the A3C algorithm**: Although the Asynchronous Advantage Actor - Critic (A3C) algorithm performs well in practical applications, its theoretical properties have not been fully understood. Specifically, non - asymptotic convergence and the performance gain brought by parallelism (i.e., linear acceleration) have not been clearly explained.
2. **Convergence conditions under theoretical assumptions**: The paper explores under what assumptions A3C can converge and whether it can converge to the global optimal solution. In addition, its convergence rate is also studied.
3. **Effects of parallel and asynchronous updates**: The paper analyzes the effects of parallel and asynchronous updates on the A3C algorithm, especially whether these characteristics can bring the effect of linear acceleration.
### Specific questions
- **Q1: Under what assumptions does A3C converge? If it converges, does it converge to the global optimal solution?**
- **Q2: What is the convergence rate of A3C?**
- **Q3: Can A3C obtain performance improvement (or linear acceleration) through parallelism and asynchrony?**
### Main contributions
The main contributions of the paper can be summarized as follows:
1. **Re - examining the convergence rate of A3C**: The paper first establishes the convergence rate of A3C under independent and identically distributed (i.i.d.) and Markov sampling. For the general function approximation case, the local convergence of A3C is proved; for the softmax policy parameterization, the global convergence is proved.
2. **Sample complexity analysis**: In the i.i.d. setting, the sample complexity of A3C is \(O(\epsilon^{- 2.5}/N)\), where \(N\) is the number of workers. Compared with the known best complexity \(O(\epsilon^{-2.5})\), A3C achieves linear acceleration. In the Markov setting, if the delay is bounded, the sample complexity of A3C is comparable to that of the non - parallel AC algorithm.
3. **Experimental verification**: The paper tests A3C through synthetic environments, classical control tasks and Atari games, verifying its theoretical guarantees.
### Technical challenges
Compared with previous studies, the analysis of A3C faces several new challenges:
1. **Coupling of Markov noise with asynchrony and delay**: A3C introduces multiple Markov chains (one for each worker), and these chains mix at different speeds, causing the slowest chain to determine the convergence.
2. **SGD linear acceleration of two - sequence coupling**: A3C is a two - time - scale stochastic semi - gradient algorithm for solving more complex bilevel optimization problems. The errors caused by asynchrony and delay are intertwined in the actor and critic updates, making accurate analysis more challenging.
### Summary
Through in - depth analysis of A3C, the paper not only fills the gap in its theoretical basis, but also provides proof of the effectiveness of parallel and asynchronous implementation, thus providing theoretical support for large - scale parallel computing in modern reinforcement learning.