Signatures of long range dipolar interactions in artificial square ice

O. Brunn,Y. Perrin,B. Canals,N. Rougemaille

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevB.103.094405

2020-12-21

Abstract:Analyzing the magnetic structure factor of a field demagnetized artificial square ice, qualitative deviations from what would predict the square ice model are observed. Combining micromagnetic and Monte Carlo simulations, we demonstrate that these deviations signal the presence of interactions between nanomagnets that extend beyond nearest neighbors. Including further neighbor, dipolar-like couplings in the square ice model, we find that the first seven or eight coupling strengths are needed to reproduce semi-quantitatively the main features of the magnetic structure factor measured experimentally. An alternative, more realistic numerical scenario is also proposed in which the ice condition is slightly detuned. In that case as well, the features evidenced in the experimental magnetic structure factor are only well-described when further neighbor couplings are taken into account. Our results show that long range dipolar interactions are not totally washed out in a field demagnetized artificial square ice, and cannot be neglected as they impact the magnetic correlations within or at the vicinity of the ice manifold.

Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics,Other Condensed Matter

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### What problems does this paper attempt to solve?

This paper aims to explore whether there are long - range dipole - dipole interactions in the artificial square ice system and verify whether these interactions can be observed in experiments. Specifically, by analyzing the magnetic structure factor (MSF) of the artificial square ice system after field - demagnetization, the authors found qualitative deviations from the predictions of the standard square ice model. These problems include:

1. **Existence of long - range dipole - dipole interactions**: Traditional square ice models only consider nearest - neighbor interactions, but in actual systems, there may be interactions beyond the nearest - neighbor. The authors hope to verify the effects of these long - range interactions through experiments and simulations.

2. **Interpretation of features in experimental observations**: Some features that cannot be explained by theoretical models were observed in the experimentally measured MSF, such as weak oscillations and extra peaks in certain wave - vector directions. The authors attempt to understand the origin of these features and determine whether they are caused by long - range interactions.

3. **Model improvement**: In order to better describe the experimental results, the authors propose a more realistic numerical model, in which not only the nearest - neighbor interactions are considered, but also the dipole - coupling strengths as far as the seventh or eighth nearest - neighbors are introduced. In this way, they hope to reproduce the main features observed in the experiments at a semi - quantitative level.

4. **Understanding of physical mechanisms**: Further study the effects of these long - range interactions on magnetic correlations, especially in the regions close to or within the ice manifold. The authors found that without considering these long - range interactions, the features of the magnetic structure factor observed in the experiments cannot be accurately described.

### Research methods

- **Experimental part**: The authors prepared an artificial square ice system and demagnetized it through a rotating, slowly decaying magnetic field. Then, magnetic force microscopy (MFM) imaging was used to calculate and analyze the average magnetic structure factor of multiple experimental results.

- **Simulation part**: Combining micromagnetic simulations and Monte Carlo simulations, the magnetic structure factor under different coupling strengths was calculated and compared with the experimental results. By gradually introducing more coupling strengths of the nearest - neighbors, the impact on MSF was evaluated.

### Conclusions

The authors conclude that long - range dipole - dipole interactions do exist in the artificial square ice system, and these interactions cannot be ignored because they significantly affect magnetic correlations. In particular, the first seven to eight coupling strengths need to be considered in order to reproduce the main features observed in the experiments at a semi - quantitative level. Moreover, even in the case of slight deviations from ice conditions, these long - range interactions still have an important impact on the magnetic structure factor.

Overall, this study reveals the existence of long - range dipole - dipole interactions in the artificial square ice system and provides a new perspective for understanding and describing the complex behaviors of these systems.