Nature-nurture interplay in educational attainment

Dilnoza Muslimova,Hans van Kippersluis,Cornelius A. Rietveld,Stephanie von Hinke,S. Fleur W. Meddens
2023-07-04
Abstract:This paper shows how nature (i.e., one's genetic endowments) and nurture (i.e., one's environment) interact in producing educational attainment. Genetic endowments are measured using a polygenic score for educational attainment, while we use birth order as an important environmental determinant of educational attainment. Since genetic endowments are randomly assigned within-families and orthogonal to one's birth order, our family fixed effects approach exploits exogenous variation in genetic endowments as well as environments. We find that those with higher genetic endowments benefit disproportionally more from being firstborn compared to those with lower genetic endowments.
General Economics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper aims to explore how genetic endowment (genes) and environmental factors (nurture) jointly influence educational achievement, with a particular focus on the interaction between the two. Specifically, the paper uses polygenic scores to measure genetic endowment and birth order as a key indicator of environmental factors. The study employs a family fixed-effects approach, leveraging the random allocation of genetic endowment within families and its orthogonality with birth order, thereby enabling the identification of causal interaction effects between genetics and environment. The research finds that individuals with higher genetic endowment gain greater educational benefits from being the firstborn compared to those with lower genetic endowment. This finding provides important causal evidence for understanding how genetics and environment jointly shape human capital and helps to refute the views of genetic determinism or environmental determinism. Additionally, the study examines the impact of birth order on educational achievement and finds that this impact varies significantly across different levels of genetic endowment, which may exacerbate intergenerational inequality.