A Threshold for Quantum Advantage in Derivative Pricing

Shouvanik Chakrabarti,Rajiv Krishnakumar,Guglielmo Mazzola,Nikitas Stamatopoulos,Stefan Woerner,William J. Zeng

DOI: https://doi.org/10.22331/q-2021-06-01-463

2021-05-26

Abstract:We give an upper bound on the resources required for valuable quantum advantage in pricing derivatives. To do so, we give the first complete resource estimates for useful quantum derivative pricing, using autocallable and Target Accrual Redemption Forward (TARF) derivatives as benchmark use cases. We uncover blocking challenges in known approaches and introduce a new method for quantum derivative pricing - the re-parameterization method - that avoids them. This method combines pre-trained variational circuits with fault-tolerant quantum computing to dramatically reduce resource requirements. We find that the benchmark use cases we examine require 8k logical qubits and a T-depth of 54 million. We estimate that quantum advantage would require executing this program at the order of a second. While the resource requirements given here are out of reach of current systems, we hope they will provide a roadmap for further improvements in algorithms, implementations, and planned hardware architectures.

Quantum Physics,Emerging Technologies,Computational Finance

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the resource conditions required to achieve quantum advantage in financial derivatives pricing. Specifically, the authors focus on how to use quantum computers to outperform classical computers in derivatives pricing, especially when dealing with path - dependent derivatives (such as autocallable options and target accrual forward contracts). Due to their complexity and computational intensity, these derivatives usually require a large amount of computational resources for simulation and pricing. Therefore, finding a method that can significantly reduce the required resources is crucial for achieving quantum advantage.

To achieve this goal, the authors propose a complete methodology, including:

1. **Resource Estimation**: For the first time, a complete resource estimate for useful quantum derivatives pricing is given, using autocallable options and target accrual forward contracts as benchmark cases.
2. **New Method**: A new quantum derivatives pricing method - the three - parameterization method (re - parameterization method) is introduced, which combines pre - trained variational circuits with fault - tolerant quantum computing and significantly reduces resource requirements.
3. **Specific Resource Requirements**: The study found that the benchmark cases examined require 8,000 logical qubits and a T - depth of 54 million. The authors estimate that achieving quantum advantage requires executing this program within seconds.
4. **Future Prospects**: Although the current system cannot yet meet these resource requirements, the authors hope that these estimates can provide an improvement roadmap for algorithms, implementation methods, and planned hardware architectures.

Through these works, the paper aims to pave the way for quantum computing applications in the financial field, especially for complex derivatives pricing problems that are difficult to be efficiently processed by traditional methods.