Flavor-dependent radiative corrections in coherent elastic neutrino-nucleus scattering

Oleksandr Tomalak,Pedro Machado,Vishvas Pandey,Ryan Plestid

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/JHEP02%282021%29097

2021-02-15

Abstract:We calculate coherent elastic neutrino-nucleus scattering cross sections on spin-0 nuclei (e.g. $^{40}$Ar and $^{28}$Si) at energies below 100 MeV within the Standard Model and account for all effects of permille size. We provide a complete error budget including uncertainties at nuclear, nucleon, hadronic, and quark levels separately as well as perturbative error. Our calculation starts from the four-fermion effective field theory to explicitly separate heavy-particle mediated corrections (which are absorbed by Wilson coefficients) from light-particle contributions. Electrons and muons running in loops introduce a nontrivial dependence on the momentum transfer due to their relatively light masses. These same loops, and those mediated by tau leptons, break the flavor universality because of mass-dependent electromagnetic radiative corrections. Nuclear physics uncertainties significantly cancel in flavor asymmetries resulting in subpercent relative errors. We find that for low neutrino energies, the cross section can be predicted with a relative precision that is competitive with neutrino-electron scattering. We highlight potentially useful applications of such a precise cross section prediction ranging from precision tests of the Standard Model, to searches for new physics and to the monitoring of nuclear reactors.

High Energy Physics - Phenomenology,High Energy Physics - Experiment,Nuclear Experiment,Nuclear Theory

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is to accurately calculate the cross - section of coherent elastic neutrino - nucleus scattering (CE νNS) on spin - 0 nuclei and consider all effects on the order of one - thousandth. Specifically, the authors calculate the radiative corrections in the CE νNS process at low energy (below 100 MeV) within the framework of the Standard Model through the four - Fermi effective field theory (EFT), and these corrections include the separation of contributions from light and heavy particles. The paper also pays special attention to the flavor - dependent radiative corrections due to different lepton masses, which break flavor universality and are of great significance for low - energy neutrino processes.

### Main research contents:
1. **Calculation of radiative corrections**:
- The paper calculates in detail the radiative corrections in the CE νNS process, especially the momentum - transfer - dependent terms introduced by electrons and muons in loop diagrams, and the violation of flavor universality by loop diagrams mediated by τ leptons.
- The authors provide a complete error budget, including uncertainties at the nuclear, nucleon, hadron, and quark levels, as well as perturbative errors.

2. **Flavor - dependent cross - section differences**:
- The cross - section differences between different - flavor neutrinos (ν_e, ν_μ, ν_τ) are studied, and these differences are significant on the order of one - thousandth.
- Flavor - dependent radiative corrections allow for the distinction of different - flavor neutrinos at low energy, which is especially important for detecting τ neutrinos because its threshold is much lower than the τ production threshold.

3. **Application prospects**:
- The paper discusses the potential applications of accurately calculating the CE νNS cross - section in multiple fields, including precise tests of the Standard Model, searches for new physics, and monitoring of nuclear reactors.
- The advantages of CE νNS at low energy are particularly emphasized, and the accuracy of its cross - section prediction can be comparable to that of neutrino - electron scattering.

### Formula summary:
- **Cross - section expression**:
\[
\frac{d\sigma_{\nu_\ell}}{dT} = \frac{G_F^2 M_A}{4\pi} \left(1 - \frac{T}{E_\nu} - \frac{M_A T}{2E_\nu^2}\right) \left(F_W(Q^2) + \frac{\alpha}{\pi} [\delta_{\nu_\ell} + \delta_{QCD}] F_{ch}(Q^2)\right)^2
\]
where \( G_F \) is the Fermi coupling constant, \( M_A \) is the mass of the nucleus, \( E_\nu \) is the energy of the incident neutrino, \( T \) is the kinetic energy of the recoiling nucleus, \( Q^2 = 2M_A T \) is the four - momentum transfer, and \( F_W(Q^2) \) and \( F_{ch}(Q^2) \) are the weak nuclear form factor and the charge form factor, respectively.

- **Radiative correction terms**:
\[
\delta_{\nu_\ell} = \frac{c_{\nu_\ell e}^L + c_{\nu_\ell e}^R}{\sqrt{2} G_F} \Pi(Q^2, m_e; \mu) + \frac{c_{\nu_\ell \mu}^L + c_{\nu_\ell \mu}^R}{\sqrt{2} G_F} \Pi(Q^2, m_\mu; \mu) + \frac{c_{\nu_\ell \tau}^L + c_{\nu_\ell \tau}^R}{\sqrt{2} G_F} \Pi(0, m_\tau; \mu)
\]
\[
\delta_{QCD} = 4 \left(\hat{\Pi}^{(3)}_{\gamma\gamma}(0; \mu) \sin^2 \theta_W - \frac{1}{2} \hat{\Pi}^{(3)}_{3\gamma}(0; \mu)\right) - \frac{N_c Q_c (c_c^L + c_c^R)}{\sqrt{2} G_F} \Pi(0, m_c; \mu)
\]