Impact of Size and Thermal Gradient on Supercooling of Phase Change Materials for Thermal Energy Storage

Drew Lilley,Jonathan Lau,Chris Dames,Sumanjeet Kaur,Ravi Prasher

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2010.11298

2020-10-22

Abstract:Phase change material based thermal energy storage has many current and potential applications in the heating and cooling of buildings, battery and electronics thermal management, thermal textiles, and dry cooling of power plants. However, connecting lab scale thermal data obtained on DSC to the performance of large-scale practical systems has been a major challenge primarily due to the dependence of supercooling on the size and temperature gradient of the system. In this work we show how a phase change material's supercooling behavior can be characterized experimentally using common lab scale thermal analysis techniques. We then develop a statistics based theoretical model that uses the lab scale data on small samples to quantitatively predict the supercooling performance for a general thermal energy storage application of any size with temperature gradients. Finally, we validate the modeling methodology by comparing to experimental results for solid-solid phase change in neopentyl glycol, which shows how the model successfully predicts the changes in supercooling temperature across a large range of cooling rates (2 orders of magnitude) and volumes (3 orders of magnitude). By accounting for thermal gradients, the model avoids ~2x error incurred by lumped approximations.

Materials Science

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper attempts to solve the problem of predicting the supercooling behavior of phase - change materials (PCMs) in thermal energy storage applications. Specifically, the paper focuses on how to relate the laboratory - scale thermal analysis data to the performance of large - scale practical systems, especially when considering the system size and temperature gradient. The following are the main problems and solutions in the paper:

### 1. **Research Background and Problems**
- **Applications of Phase - Change Materials (PCMs)**: PCMs are widely used in building heating and cooling, thermal management of batteries and electronic devices, thermal textiles, and dry cooling in power plants.
- **Technical Challenges**: Thermal data analysis at the laboratory scale (such as differential scanning calorimetry DSC) is difficult to accurately predict the performance of large - scale practical systems. The main reason is that the supercooling phenomenon depends on the system size and temperature gradient.
- **Impact of Supercooling Phenomenon**: Supercooling refers to the phenomenon that the actual phase - change temperature of a material is lower than its theoretical equilibrium phase - change temperature. This phenomenon can significantly affect the performance of PCMs in practical applications, especially in applications requiring precise temperature control (such as temperature regulation in buildings).

### 2. **Core Problems of the Paper**
- **How to Predict the Supercooling Behavior of Large - Scale Systems from Laboratory - Scale Data**: Existing experimental data are usually obtained on small samples, while the system scale in practical applications is much larger and there are temperature gradients. Therefore, how to extend these small - sample data to larger - scale systems is a key challenge.
- **Limitations of Existing Models**: Most numerical models ignore the supercooling effect, leading to overly optimistic predictions of system performance. In addition, although the classical nucleation theory provides physical insights, its input parameters are difficult to determine in advance, which limits its predictive ability.

### 3. **Solutions**
- **Establishment of a Statistical Model**: The paper proposes a statistical - based theoretical model that uses small - sample data at the laboratory scale to quantitatively predict the supercooling behavior under any scale and temperature - gradient conditions.
- **Application of Non - homogeneous Poisson Process**: By introducing a non - homogeneous Poisson process to describe the nucleation rate, this model can capture the time and spatial distribution characteristics of nucleation events.
- **Influence of Volume and Cooling Rate**: The model takes into account the influence of volume and cooling rate on the supercooling temperature and verifies its effectiveness through experiments.
- **Standardized Definition**: In order to facilitate the comparison of the supercooling performance of different materials, the paper proposes a standardized reference system (1 - liter volume, 1°C/min cooling rate) and defines a standard supercooling temperature.

### 4. **Experimental Verification**
- **Material Selection**: Neopentyl glycol (NPG) was selected as the research object because it has a clear phase - change temperature (40.8°C) and does not react with the DSC aluminum pan.
- **Experimental Design**: The nucleation rate parameters of NPG were obtained through DSC experiments, and large - scale cooling experiments were carried out to verify the accuracy of the model predictions.
- **Result Comparison**: The experimental results show that the model successfully predicts the changes in supercooling temperature under different volumes and cooling rates, verifying the effectiveness of the model.

### Summary
This paper aims to solve the problem of predicting the supercooling behavior of phase - change materials in large - scale applications. By establishing a statistical model and combining experimental verification, it provides a method for deriving the performance of large - scale systems from laboratory data, thereby providing theoretical support and technical guidance for the practical applications of phase - change materials.