Intrinsic motivation in virtual assistant interaction for fostering spontaneous interactions

Chang Li,Hideyoshi Yanagisawa

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0250326

2020-10-13

Abstract:With the growing utility of today's conversational virtual assistants, the importance of user motivation in human-AI interaction is becoming more obvious. However, previous studies in this and related fields, such as human-computer interaction and human-robot interaction, scarcely discussed intrinsic motivation and its affecting factors. Those studies either treated motivation as an inseparable concept or focused on non-intrinsic motivation. The current study aims to cover intrinsic motivation by taking an affective-engineering approach. A novel motivation model is proposed, in which intrinsic motivation is affected by two factors that derive from user interactions with virtual assistants: expectation of capability and uncertainty. Experiments are conducted where these two factors are manipulated by making participants believe they are interacting with the smart speaker "Amazon Echo". Intrinsic motivation is measured both by using questionnaires and by covertly monitoring a five-minute free-choice period in the experimenter's absence, during which the participants could decide for themselves whether to interact with the virtual assistants. Results of the first experiment showed that high expectation engenders more intrinsically motivated interaction compared with low expectation. The results also suggested suppressive effects by uncertainty on intrinsic motivation, though we had not hypothesized before experiments. We then revised our hypothetical model of action selection accordingly and conducted a verification experiment of uncertainty's effects. Results of the verification experiment showed that reducing uncertainty encourages more interactions and causes the motivation behind these interactions to shift from non-intrinsic to intrinsic.

Human-Computer Interaction,Artificial Intelligence,Robotics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to promote spontaneous interaction in virtual assistant interactions, especially by enhancing users' intrinsic motivation. Specifically, the research focuses on how two factors affect users' intrinsic motivation: Expectation of Capability and Uncertainty. Researchers hope to design strategies that can stimulate users to interact spontaneously with virtual assistants by understanding and adjusting these two factors, thereby increasing the attractiveness and usage rate of the product.

The paper proposes a new motivation model in which intrinsic motivation is affected by users' expectations and uncertainties when interacting with virtual assistants. To verify this model, researchers designed a series of experiments. By manipulating participants' expectations and uncertainties, they observed how these factors affected participants' spontaneous interaction behaviors with virtual assistants. The experimental results showed that high expectations can generate more intrinsically - motivated interactions, while uncertainty has an inhibitory effect on intrinsic motivation. Researchers revised their hypothesized model based on these results and further verified the influence of uncertainty.

In summary, this research aims to provide theoretical basis and practical suggestions for the future design of virtual assistants by exploring and understanding the mechanism of intrinsic motivation in virtual assistant interactions, so as to promote users to interact with virtual assistants more actively and more naturally.