Brittany Richman,Jacob M. Taylor
Abstract:Magnetic fields break time-reversal symmetry, which is leveraged in many settings to enable the nonreciprocal behavior of light. This is the core physics of circulators and other elements used in a variety of microwave and optical settings. Commercial circulators in the microwave domain typically use ferromagnetic materials and wave interference, requiring large devices and large fields. However, quantum information devices for sensing and computation require small sizes, lower fields, and better on-chip integration. Equivalences to ferromagnetic order -- such as the XY model -- can be realized at much lower magnetic fields by using arrays of superconducting islands connected by Josephson junctions. Here we show that the quantum-coherent motion of a single vortex in such an array suffices to induce nonreciprocal behavior, enabling a small-scale, moderate-bandwidth, and low insertion loss circulator at very low magnetic fields and at microwave frequencies relevant for experiments with qubits.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the challenge of miniaturization and low - magnetic - field operation in realizing signal routing and isolation in quantum computing devices. Specifically, traditional commercial circulators are difficult to be applied in large - scale quantum computing systems because of their large volume and the need for strong magnetic fields to work. The paper proposes a new method, which utilizes the quantum - coherent motion of a single vortex in a superconducting - island array to induce non - reciprocal behavior, thereby realizing a circulator with miniaturization, moderate bandwidth, and low insertion loss, suitable for microwave frequencies related to qubit experiments and capable of working under very low magnetic fields.
### Background of the Paper and Problem Definition
1. **Requirements of Quantum Computing Devices**:
- As the scale of quantum computing devices expands, the hardware supporting qubits must be correspondingly reduced in size.
- Key components include circulators for signal routing and isolation, low - noise amplifiers, filters, and cooling systems.
2. **Limitations of Traditional Circulators**:
- Traditional circulators usually use ferromagnetic materials and wave interference and require large - scale devices and strong magnetic fields.
- The application of these circulators in large - scale quantum computing systems is challenged because they are bulky and require high magnetic fields.
3. **Physical Principles of Non - Reciprocal Behavior**:
- Creating a circulator requires inducing non - reciprocal behavior through explicit or implicit breaking of time - reversal symmetry.
- Commercial ferromagnetic - junction circulators utilize the Faraday effect to achieve one - way signal transmission through the interaction between the magnetic field generated by a permanent magnet and the ferromagnetic disk in the center of the device.
### The Method Proposed in the Paper
1. **Vortex Motion in the Superconducting - Island Array**:
- The paper proposes to use the quantum - coherent motion of a single vortex in a superconducting - island array to induce non - reciprocal behavior.
- By inserting additional Josephson junctions, it switches from Cooper - pair tunneling devices to persistent - current (vortex) tunneling devices.
2. **Model Circuit**:
- The model circuit is composed of three superconducting islands connected by Josephson junctions, and an external flux \(\Phi\) passes through the entire circuit.
- The Hamiltonian \(H_{CC}\) of the circuit includes a charging - energy term and a Josephson - energy term, and its specific form is as follows:
\[
H_{CC} = 4E_{\Sigma} (\hat{N} - N_g)^T K^{-1} (\hat{N} - N_g) + E_J V(\hat{\phi}, \Phi)
\]
- Among them, \(E_{\Sigma}=\frac{e^2}{2C_M}\), \(C_M\) is the maximum eigenvalue of the circuit capacitance matrix, \(K^{-1}\) is a dimensionless inverse - capacitance matrix, and \(V(\hat{\phi}, \Phi)\) is the tunneling potential.
3. **Vortex Behavior and Non - Reciprocity**:
- By adjusting the relative magnitudes of the Josephson energy \(E_J\) and the charging energy \(E_C\), making the system in the intermediate tunneling region can reduce the influence of charge noise while maintaining the quantum - coherent motion of the vortex.
- When \(E_J\sim E_C\), the vortex can move and charge noise may be reduced, thereby achieving noise - resistant non - reciprocity.
### Conclusion
The paper proposes a new circulator design based on vortex motion in a superconducting - island array, which can work under very low magnetic fields and has the characteristics of miniaturization, low insertion loss, and moderate bandwidth. This design is expected to achieve effective signal routing and isolation in large - scale quantum computing systems.