Abstract:Policies embracing circular economy concepts have taken hold in national legislation around the world. As the number of governments and organizations adopting circular economy policies increases, so does the need for accurate and timely measurement of material resource flows. Since many countries do not have access to centrally reported municipal solid waste (MSW) data, estimation and modeling are critical in evaluating circular economy policy effectiveness. The purpose of this paper is to examine three modeling approaches estimating national MSW data in the United States, including industry-based material flow analysis, waste-extended input-output modeling, and aggregated regional waste reporting. We establish five criteria to guide the analysis through the context of policy monitoring (data quality, flow totality, update frequency, sensitivity to disruption, and product granularity) and use these criteria to analyze and score each model. We then use a literature search to identify five, internationally-implemented options for circular economy policy and determine the data and modeling components that are most helpful in evaluating policy effectiveness. Finally, we provide a crosswalk of the model scores and policy needs to inform the suitability of model selection by policy type. We found that data quality and update frequency are identified as critical components for evaluating circular economy policies within the models evaluated, and can both be fulfilled by aggregated regional waste reporting. Flow totality, sensitivity to disruption, and product granularity requirements vary by both model and policy types. While none of the evaluated models satisfy the combination of requirements for any of the five policies, industry-based material flow analysis offers flow totality for extended producer responsibility, landfill bans, and recycling rate target policies that typically require it. The waste-extended input-output model can provide disruption sensitivity and product granularity as needed for policies like minimum recycled content and market restrictions. Policy developers in areas where strong centralized data collection is not an option should design policy action(s) with modeling tradeoffs in mind, including the potential hybridization of modeling approaches that may provide the most accurate national MSW estimates.

Policy evaluation of waste pricing programs using heterogeneous causal effect estimation

Implications of Overlap in Tariff Policy on Waste Management Costs in Italian Municipalities

Testing data envelopment analysis models on the performance of European Union regions in sustainable waste management

Pay as You Throw Threshold Tariff: Evidence on the Incentive to Recycle

Municipal waste management: A complex network approach with an application to Italy

Causal impact evaluation of occupational safety policies on firms' default using machine learning uplift modelling

Modelling Network Interference with Multi-valued Treatments: the Causal Effect of Immigration Policy on Crime Rates

Does gender affect environmentally virtuous behaviour? Evidence from selective waste collection

The Crowding-Out Effects Of Garbage Fees And Voluntary Source Separation Programs On Waste Reduction: Evidence From China

Gender politics, environmental behaviours, and local territories: Evidence from Italian municipalities

Positive Research of Pay-as-you-throw Policy Effects

Understanding the trade-offs of national municipal solid waste estimation methods for circular economy policy

Assessing the Monetary Value and Environmental Impact of Household Food Waste in Italy

Community-Level Household Waste Disposal Behavior Simulation and Visualization under Multiple Incentive Policies-An Agent-Based Modelling Approach

An Econometric Model for the Analysis of the Influence of the Refurbishment Costs on Housing Prices

Co-payment exemption and healthcare consumption: quasi-experimental evidence from Italy

Waste recycling policies and Covid-19 pandemic in an E-DSGE model

The impact of local cost-of-living differences on relative poverty incidence: an application using retail scanner data and small area estimation models

Complementarity vs substitutability in waste management behaviors

Meeting the challenges of the waste hierarchy: A performance evaluation of EU countries

Incentivizing Household Recycling Crowds out Public Support for Other Waste Management Policies: A Long-Term Quasi-Experimental Study