Abstract:Local social interactions among individuals in animal groups generate collective behavior, allowing groups to adjust to changing conditions. Historically, scientists from different disciplines have taken different approaches to modeling collective behavior. We describe how each can contribute to the goal of understanding natural systems. Simple bottom-up models that describe individuals and their interactions directly have demonstrated that local interactions far from equilibrium can generate collective states. However, such simple models are not likely to describe accurately the actual mechanisms and interactions in play in any real biological system. Other classes of top-down models that describe group-level behavior directly have been proposed for groups where the function of the collective behavior is understood. Such models cannot necessarily explain why or how such functions emerge from first principles. Because modeling approaches have different strengths and weaknesses and no single approach will always be best, we argue that models of collective behavior that are aimed at understanding real biological systems should be formulated to address specific questions and to allow for validation. As examples, we discuss four forms of collective behavior that differ both in the interactions that produce the collective behavior and in ecological context, and thus require very different modeling frameworks. 1) Harvester ants use local interactions consisting of brief antennal contact, in which one ant assesses the cuticular hydrocarbon profile of another, to regulate foraging activity, which can be modeled as a closed-loop excitable system. 2) Arboreal turtle ants form trail networks in the canopy of the tropical forest, using trail pheromone; one ant detects the volatile chemical that another has recently deposited. The process that maintains and repairs the trail, which can be modeled as a distributed algorithm, is constrained by the physical configuration of the network of vegetation in which they travel. 3) Swarms of midges interact acoustically and non-locally, and can be well described as agents moving in an emergent potential well that is representative of the swarm as a whole rather than individuals. 4) Flocks of jackdaws change their effective interactions depending on ecological context, using topological distance when traveling but metric distance when mobbing. We discuss how different research questions about these systems have led to different modeling approaches.

Ants, robots, humans: a self-organizing, complex systems modeling approach

A Self-organisation Model for Mobile Robots in Large Structure Assembly Using Multi-agent Systems

The Design Of A Network-Structured Artificial Social System Based On Agent-Based Modeling

Goals and Limitations of Modeling Collective Behavior in Biological Systems

The Bacterial Chemotactic Response Reflects a Compromise Between Transient and Steady State Behavior

Self-Organizing Software Models for the Internet of Things Complex Software Structures That Emerge Without a Central Controller

Morphogenetic self-organization of collective systems.

Automated optimisation of multi-level models of collective behaviour in a mixed society of animals and robots

A framework for modeling human behavior in large-scale agent-based epidemic simulations

Using Intelligent Agents to understand organisational behaviour

Evolving Network Motifs Based Morphogenetic Approach To Self-Organizing Robotic Swarms

Simulation Model for the Studying of the Self-organizing Team

Empirical characterisation of agent behaviours in socio-ecological systems

Psychologically-Valid Generative Agents: A Novel Approach to Agent-Based Modeling in Social Sciences

An Intelligent Control and Decision Making Model Based on Self-Organizing Multi-Agent System

Morphogenetic Self-Organisation of Swarm Robots for Adaptive Pattern Formation

Modeling Adaptive Autonomous Agents for Intelligent Robots

Modelling Multi-agent Systems with Soft Genes, Roles, and Agents

Artificial Intelligence for Modeling Complex Systems: Taming the Complexity of Expert Models to Improve Decision Making

Offline Emergence Engineering For Agent Societies

A Self-Replication Basis for Designing Complex Agents