Abstract:We study the approximation properties and optimization dynamics of recurrent neural networks (RNNs) when applied to learn input-output relationships in temporal data. We consider the simple but representative setting of using continuous-time linear RNNs to learn from data generated by linear relationships. Mathematically, the latter can be understood as a sequence of linear functionals. We prove a universal approximation theorem of such linear functionals, and characterize the approximation rate and its relation with memory. Moreover, we perform a fine-grained dynamical analysis of training linear RNNs, which further reveal the intricate interactions between memory and learning. A unifying theme uncovered is the non-trivial effect of memory, a notion that can be made precise in our framework, on approximation and optimization: when there is long term memory in the target, it takes a large number of neurons to approximate it. Moreover, the training process will suffer from slow downs. In particular, both of these effects become exponentially more pronounced with memory - a phenomenon we call the "curse of memory". These analyses represent a basic step towards a concrete mathematical understanding of new phenomenon that may arise in learning temporal relationships using recurrent architectures.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper attempts to address two core theoretical issues related to Recurrent Neural Networks (RNNs) when handling time series data: approximation capability and optimization dynamics. 1. **Approximation Capability**: The paper investigates the approximation capability of RNNs in representing the input-output relationships of time series data. Specifically, the authors explore whether RNNs can model specific time input-output relationships with arbitrary precision and analyze the rate of such approximation. 2. **Optimization Dynamics**: The paper also studies the optimization dynamics when training RNNs, particularly the behavior of the gradient descent method during the training process. Through detailed dynamic analysis, the authors reveal the impact of memory (i.e., the system's dependence on past inputs) on the optimization process. ### Main Findings 1. **Approximation Theory**: - The authors prove a general approximation theorem, showing that continuous-time linear RNNs can approximate a class of linear functionals with arbitrary precision. - They further analyze the approximation rate, finding that it is closely related to the smoothness and memory characteristics of the target functional. Specifically, when the target functional has long-term memory, more neurons are required to achieve the approximation, and the approximation error grows exponentially with the length of the memory, a phenomenon referred to as the "curse of memory." 2. **Optimization Dynamics**: - The authors conduct a detailed analysis of the optimization dynamics of training linear RNNs using the gradient descent method, discovering that when the target functional has long-term memory, the training process exhibits significant slow convergence, characterized by the training loss remaining almost unchanged for a period (i.e., a "plateau"). - This plateau phenomenon is validated in various experiments, including both linear RNNs and nonlinear RNNs (such as the Lorenz 96 dynamical system). ### Conclusion Through mathematical analysis and experimental validation, the paper reveals the profound impact of memory effects on the approximation capability and optimization dynamics of RNNs. These results not only provide a theoretical foundation for understanding the behavior of RNNs in handling time series data but also offer new perspectives for improving the design and training methods of RNNs. In particular, the concept of the "curse of memory" highlights the challenges RNNs face when dealing with data that has long-term dependencies.

On the Curse of Memory in Recurrent Neural Networks: Approximation and Optimization Analysis

Approximation and Optimization Theory for Linear Continuous-Time Recurrent Neural Networks

Inverse Approximation Theory for Nonlinear Recurrent Neural Networks

Approximation Performance Analysis of Recurrent Neural Networks.

Memory and Information Processing in Recurrent Neural Networks

Universal Approximation Property of Stochastic Configuration Networks for Time Series

One Step Back, Two Steps Forward: Interference and Learning in Recurrent Neural Networks

Approximation to Nonlinear Discrete-Time Systems by Recurrent Neural Networks.

Optimization and Generalization of Regularization-Based Continual Learning: a Loss Approximation Viewpoint

Deep Neural Networks with ReLU-Sine-Exponential Activations Break Curse of Dimensionality in Approximation on Hölder Class.

Kernel Limit of Recurrent Neural Networks Trained on Ergodic Data Sequences

Forward and Inverse Approximation Theory for Linear Temporal Convolutional Networks

Learning Longer Memory in Recurrent Neural Networks

Short-term Sequence Memory: Compressive Effects of Recurrent Network Dynamics

Recurrent Neural Networks with Finite Memory Length

Learning Low Dimensional State Spaces with Overparameterized Recurrent Neural Nets

End-to-End Incomplete Time-Series Modeling From Linear Memory of Latent Variables

Neural Network Approximations of Compositional Functions With Applications to Dynamical Systems

Optimal Rates of Approximation by Shallow ReLU Neural Networks and Applications to Nonparametric Regression

Finite-Time Analysis of Adaptive Temporal Difference Learning with Deep Neural Networks

On the Long-Term Memory of Deep Recurrent Networks