Abstract:Based on the observation that many existing discrete choice models admit a welfare function of utilities whose gradient gives the choice probability vector, we propose a new representation of discrete choice model which we call the welfare-based choice model. The welfare-based choice model is meaningful on its own by providing a new way of constructing choice models. More importantly, it provides great analysis convenience for establishing connections among existing choice models. We prove by using convex analysis theory, that the welfare-based choice model is equivalent to the representative agent choice model and the semi-parametric choice model, establishing the equivalence of the latter two. We show that these three models are all strictly more general than the random utility model, while when there are only two alternatives, those four models are equivalent. In particular, we show that the distinction between the welfare-based choice model and the random utility model lies in the requirement of the higher-order derivatives of the welfare function. We then define a new concept in choice models: substitutability/complementarity between alternatives. We show that the random utility model only allows substitutability between different alternatives; while the welfare-based choice model allows flexible substitutability/complementarity patterns. We argue that such flexibility could be desirable in capturing certain practical choice patterns and expanding the scope of discrete choice models. Examples are given of new choice models proposed under our framework.

Counterfactual and Welfare Analysis with an Approximate Model

Individual Welfare Analysis: Random Quasilinear Utility, Independence, and Confidence Bounds

Approximation-Robust Inference in Dynamic Discrete Choice

Nonparametric Counterfactuals in Random Utility Models

Welfare Analysis in Dynamic Models

Analysis of Discrete Choice Models: A Welfare-Based Framework

A Welfare Analysis of Tariffs and Equivalent Quotas under Demand Uncertainty: Implications for Tariffication

Real Analytic Discrete Choice Models Of Demand: Theory And Implications

Discrete-Choice Models and Representative Consumer Theory

Welfare Analysis via Marginal Treatment Effects

Nonparametric estimation of structural labor supply and exact welfare change under nonconvex piecewise-linear budget sets

A model‐free approximation for barrier options in a general stochastic volatility framework

Nonparametric Approaches to Empirical Welfare Analysis

Counterfactual Sensitivity and Robustness

Approximating One-Sided and Two-Sided Nash Social Welfare With Capacities

Functional Forms, Exogenous Shifts, and Economic Surplus Changes

Approximate Expected Utility Rationalization

Welfare Analysis in a Two-Stage Inverse Demand Model: An Application to Harvest Changes in the Chesapeake Bay

The Empirical Content of Binary Choice Models

Model-based Utility Functions

Approximating the Price Effects of Mergers : Numerical Evidence and an Empirical Application