Should a small robot have a small personal space? Investigating personal spatial zones and proxemic behavior in human-robot interaction

Hagen Lehmann,Adam Rojik,Matej Hoffmann

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2009.01818

2020-09-04

Abstract:This paper presents the first study in a series of proxemics experiments concerned with the role of personal spatial zones in human-robot interaction. In the study 40 participants approached a NAO robot positioned approximately at participants' eye level and entered different social zones around the robot (personal and intimate space). When the robot perceived the approaching person entering its personal space, it started gazing at the participant, and upon the intrusion of its intimate space it leaned back. Our research questions were: (1) given the small size of the robot (58 cm tall), will people expect its social zones to shrink by its size? (2) Will the robot behaviors be interpreted as appropriate social behaviors? We found that the average approach distance of the participants was 48 cm, which represents the inner limit of the human-size personal zone (45-120 cm), but is outside of the personal zone scaled to robot size (16-42 cm). This suggests that most participants did not (fully) scale down the extent of these zones to the robot size. We also found that the leaning back behavior of the robot was correctly interpreted by most participants as the robot's reaction to the intrusion of its personal space; however, our implementation of the behavior was often perceived as "unfriendly". We will discuss this and other limitations of the study in detail. Additionally we found positive correlations between participants' personality traits, Godspeed Questionnaire subscales, and the average approach distance. The technical contribution of this work is the real-time perception of 25 keypoints on the human body using a single compact RGB-D camera and the use of these points for accurate interpersonal distance estimation and as gazing targets for the robot.

Human-Computer Interaction

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problems that this paper attempts to solve mainly focus on the application and understanding of Personal Spatial Zones (PSZ) in human - robot interaction. Specifically, the researchers explored the following issues:

1. **The influence of robot size on personal space**: Will people expect the personal space of a robot to be correspondingly reduced because of its small size? That is, do people think that small robots should have smaller personal spaces?

2. **The social acceptance of robot behaviors**: Will the personal - space - invasion reactions (such as gazing, leaning back) exhibited by robots be correctly interpreted as appropriate social behaviors by participants? Are these behaviors considered friendly or unfriendly?

3. **The distance selection when humans interact with robots**: When interacting with robots, will participants adjust the distance between themselves and the robots according to the size of the robots, or more based on their own comfort?

### Research Background

Personal Spatial Zones (PSZ) is an important concept in human social interaction, which describes the physical distance range in which an individual feels comfortable in different social situations. In the field of Human - Robot Interaction (HRI), understanding and simulating this concept is crucial for designing more natural and comfortable robot behaviors.

### Research Methods

To answer the above questions, the researchers designed a series of experiments, using a 58 - centimeter - high NAO robot and placing it on a platform so that its height was close to the eye level of the participants. The experiments included three conditions:

- **Control condition**: The robot randomly exhibited gazing and leaning - back behaviors.
- **Robot scale condition**: When participants entered the personal space (16 - 42 centimeters) scaled according to the robot size, the robot exhibited corresponding behaviors.
- **Human scale condition**: When participants entered the personal space (45 - 120 centimeters) defined according to human size, the robot exhibited corresponding behaviors.

### Experimental Results

1. **Average approach distance**: The average approach distance of the participants was 47.7 centimeters, which was close to the personal space range of human scale (45 - 120 centimeters), but much larger than the personal space range scaled according to the robot size (16 - 42 centimeters). This indicates that most participants did not fully adjust the distance between themselves and the robots according to the size of the robots.

2. **Behavior interpretation**: Although most participants correctly interpreted the robot's leaning - back behavior as a reaction to personal - space invasion, they generally considered this behavior "unfriendly".

3. **Correlation between personality traits and approach distance**: The study found that there was a positive correlation between certain personality traits of the participants (such as agreeableness and conscientiousness) and the distance they maintained from the robots.

### Conclusion

This study shows that although the robots exhibited clear personal - space - invasion reactions, the participants did not fully adjust their behaviors according to the size of the robots. In addition, some behaviors exhibited by the robots (such as leaning back) may need further optimization to ensure that they are interpreted as friendly and natural behaviors.

### Future Work

Future research can further explore how to optimize the non - verbal behaviors of robots to make them more in line with human social expectations. At the same time, different cultural and situational factors affecting personal space can also be considered, as well as how to apply these research results in more complex environments.