Pain relief in pancreatic disease
Åke Andrén‐Sandberg
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1046/j.1365-2168.1997.02840.x
1997-08-01
Abstract:The World Health Organization has designated pain relief and palliative care as priorities in its global programme for cancer control. About 80 per cent of all patients with exocrine pancreatic cancer have pain as an initial symptom and practically all will suffer significant pain at some stage before they succumb to the disease'. Pain is also the cardinal symptom in chronic pancreatitis and, together with the usual problem of contemporary alcoholism, is the most difficult feature to treat2. For some patients with these diseases the pain is so severe that all waking hours are devoted to its control; quality of life is very poor. While these diseases are rarely cured, they can, at best, be rendered symptom free. The management of symptoms should, therefore, be of prime concern in most individuals with these serious pancreatic pathologies. For both pancreatic cancer and chronic pancreatitis resection of the diseased part of the gland seems to be the most logical treatment and it should always be considered as the first option3. Nevertheless, when it is clear that cure is not within reach, pain relief may be provided by simpler procedures directed against the afferent nerves that carry the painful stimuli from the diseased organ to the brain. The sympathetic innervation of the pancreas, including the nerves transmitting pain, depends on cells in the intermediolateral tract of the spinal cord from Th 5 to Th 11. The sympathetic fibres from the cord run to the sympathetic chain and, thereafter, via the major splanchnic nerve (from Th 5 to Th 10) and one or more minor splanchnic nerves (from Th 9 to Th 11) to synapses in prevertebral abdominal plexuses, in the present case specifically to the coeliac ganglion. From a theoretical point of view pancreatic pain might be inhibited by interrupting the nerve fibres anywhere along these paths. In previous years chemical splanchnicectomy was carried out but, although it was not without success, the results were unpredi~table~.~. As the pain fibres run in the sympathetic chain, pain stimuli can be overcome from within the thoracic cavity where the chain lies immediately subpleurally in a wave-like disposition oyer the ribs in the posterior mediastinum. These nerves are identified easily at thoracoscopy. Thoracoscopic splanchnicectomy may be performed bilaterally under general anaesthesia using double-lumen endotracheal intubation. In a series of 30 patients treated in Lund, satisfactory stable pain relief was obtained from the first week after surgery to a median follow-up time of 18 months. All but one patient reported clearly reduced pain, but only 17 per cent of individuals reported immediate complete pain relief. One may conclude that thoracoscopic splanchnicectomy appears promising as a relatively simple treatment for severe chronic pancreatic pain6. Nevertheless, it must be appreciated that the effect of splanchnicectomy is difficult to assess in such patients because of their preoperative addiction to alcohol and strong analgesics7. It seems possible that the results in the prospectively followed group of patients in Lund might have been better if they had not been exposed to strong analgesics for a long time and, indeed, if the duration of the pain had itself been limited. Those with established chronic pancreatitis or pancreatic cancer do not present with features that are uniformly related to the stage of their disease, or to extrapancreatic secondary symptomatology or to morphological features. This lack of uniformity also influences the pattern of pain and the outcome of attempts at management, not only of symptoms but of the patient as a whole. Initially, the cornerstone of management is a stepwise escalation of analgesics; it is wise to provide patients with full information on their condition and its treatment in order that they themselves may be involved in the management process. At some stage, however, rather than crossing the borderline into narcotic usage or turning to palliative resection, it may be useful to consider other methods of pain control. In the light of what is now known, thoracoscopic splanchnicectomy seems a good option; its precise role will become better defined over the next few years. In those