Abstract:We study Satisfiability Modulo Theories (SMT) enriched with the so-called Ramsey quantifiers, which assert the existence of cliques (complete graphs) in the graph induced by some formulas. The extended framework is known to have applications in proving program termination (in particular, whether a transitive binary predicate is well-founded), and monadic decomposability of SMT formulas. Our main result is a new algorithm for eliminating Ramsey quantifiers from three common SMT theories: Linear Integer Arithmetic (LIA), Linear Real Arithmetic (LRA), and Linear Integer Real Arithmetic (LIRA). In particular, if we work only with existentially quantified formulas, then our algorithm runs in polynomial time and produces a formula of linear size. One immediate consequence is that checking well-foundedness of a given formula in the aforementioned theory defining a transitive predicate can be straightforwardly handled by highly optimized SMT-solvers. We show also how this provides a uniform semi-algorithm for verifying termination and liveness with completeness guarantee (in fact, with an optimal computational complexity) for several well-known classes of infinite-state systems, which include succinct timed systems, one-counter systems, and monotonic counter systems. Another immediate consequence is a solution to an open problem on checking monadic decomposability of a given relation in quantifier-free fragments of LRA and LIRA, which is an important problem in automated reasoning and constraint databases. Our result immediately implies decidability of this problem with an optimal complexity (coNP-complete) and enables exploitation of SMT-solvers. It also provides a termination guarantee for the generic monadic decomposition algorithm of Veanes et al. for LIA, LRA, and LIRA. We report encouraging experimental results on a prototype implementation of our algorithms on micro-benchmarks.

First-order axiomatisations of representable relation algebras need formulas of unbounded quantifier depth

On sets of first-order formulas axiomatizing representable relation algebras

Cyclic Group Spectra for Some Small Relation Algebras

Efficient Implementation of an Abstract Domain of Quantified First-Order Formulas

Strongly representable atom structures and neat embeddings

Complete representation by partial functions for signatures containing antidomain restriction

Finite Representation Property for Relation Algebra Reducts

Algebraic Reasoning over Relational Structures

First-Order Quantification over Automata

Quantifier-free formulas and quantifier alternation depth in doctrines

Quantifier Free Definability on Infinite Algebras

Ramsey Quantifiers in Linear Arithmetics

Comer Schemes, Relation Algebras, and the Flexible Atom Conjecture

Non elementary classes of relation and cylindric algebras

Finite Variable Counting Logics with Restricted Requantification

Bounded arithmetic AID for Frege system

Amount algebras

Incompleteness of boundedly axiomatizable theories

The Precise Complexity of Reasoning in $\mathcal{ALC}$ with $ω$-Admissible Concrete Domains (Extended Version)

A Completeness Result for Inequational Reasoning in a Full Higher-Order Setting