Purely cosmetic surgeries and pretzel knots

András I. Stipsicz,Zoltán Szabó

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2140/pjm.2021.313.195

2020-06-12

Abstract:We show that all pretzel knots satisfy the (purely) cosmetic surgery conjecture, i.e. Dehn surgeries with different slopes along a pretzel knot provide different oriented three-manifolds.

Geometric Topology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Alternating odd pretzel knots and chirally cosmetic surgeries

Konstantinos Varvarezos

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1142/S0218216522500456

2022-07-12

Journal of Knot Theory and Its Ramifications

Abstract:A pair of surgeries on a knot is chirally cosmetic if they result in homeomorphic manifolds with opposite orientations. Using recent methods of Ichihara, Ito, and Saito, we show that, except for the (2, 5) and (2, 7)-torus knots, the genus 2 and 3 alternating odd pretzel knots do not admit any chirally cosmetic surgeries. Further, we show that for a fixed genus, at most finitely many alternating odd pretzel knots admit chirally cosmetic surgeries.

mathematics
3-braid knots do not admit purely cosmetic surgeries

K. Varvarezos

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10474-020-01129-z

2021-02-06

Acta Mathematica Hungarica

Abstract:A pair of surgeries on a knot is called purely cosmetic if thepair of resulting 3-manifolds are homeomorphic as oriented manifolds. An outstandingconjecture predicts that no nontrivial knots admit any purely cosmeticsurgeries. Recent work of Hanselman [5] uses Heegaard Floer homology to obtainnew obstructions for the existence of such surgeries. In this work, we applythose obstructions to show that (nontrivial) knots which arise as the closure of a3-stranded braid do not admit any purely cosmetic surgeries.

mathematics
Connected sums of knots do not admit purely cosmetic surgeries

Ran Tao

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1909.05048

2019-09-11

Geometric Topology

Abstract:Two Dehn surgeries on a knot are called purely cosmetic if their surgered manifolds are homeomorphic as oriented manifolds. Gordon conjectured that non-trivial knots in $S^3$ do not admit purely cosmetic surgeries. In this article, we confirm this conjecture for connected sums of knots by analysing the JSJ-structures.
Cable knots do not admit cosmetic surgeries

Ran Tao

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1142/S0218216519500342

2019-10-07

Journal of Knot Theory and Its Ramifications

Abstract:Two Dehn surgeries on a knot are called purely cosmetic if their surgered manifolds are homeomorphic as oriented manifolds. Gordon conjectured that nontrivial knots in S3 do not admit purely cosmetic surgeries. In this paper, we confirm this conjecture for cable knots.

mathematics
Excluding cosmetic surgeries on hyperbolic 3-manifolds

David Futer,Jessica S. Purcell,Saul Schleimer

2024-04-11

Abstract:This paper employs knot invariants and results from hyperbolic geometry to develop a practical procedure for checking the cosmetic surgery conjecture on any given one-cusped manifold. This procedure has been used to establish the following computational results. First, we verify that all knots up to 19 crossings, and all one-cusped 3-manifolds in the SnapPy census, do not admit any purely cosmetic surgeries. Second, we check that a hyperbolic knot with at most 15 crossings only admits chirally cosmetic surgeries when the knot itself is amphicheiral. Third, we enumerate all knots up to 13 crossings that share a common Dehn fillings with the figure-8 knot. The code that verifies these results is publicly available on GitHub.

Geometric Topology
Cosmetic surgery on knots

Steven A. Bleiler,Craig D. Hodgson,Jeffrey R. Weeks

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.math/9911247

1999-11-17

Geometric Topology

Abstract:This paper concerns the Dehn surgery construction, especially those Dehn surgeries leaving the manifold unchanged. In particular, we describe an oriented 1-cusped hyperbolic 3-manifold X with a pair of slopes r_1, r_2 such that the Dehn filled manifolds X(r_1), X(r_2) are oppositely oriented copies of the lens space L(49,18), and there is no homeomorphism h of X such that h(r_1)=h(r_2).
Special alternating knots with sufficiently many twist regions have no chirally cosmetic surgeries

Tetsuya Ito

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2301.09855

2023-01-24

Geometric Topology

Abstract:We show that a special alternating knot with sufficiently large number (more than $63$) of twist regions has no chirally cosmetic surgeries, a pair of Dehn surgeries producing orientation-reversingly homeomorphic $3$-manifolds. In the course of proof, we provide the optimal upper bounds of the primitive finite type invariants of degree 2 and 3 that solve Willerton's conjecture.
Large alternating Montesinos knots do not admit purely cosmetic surgeries

Kazuhiro Ichihara,In Dae Jong

2024-06-06

Abstract:It is conjectured that, on a non-trivial knot in the 3-sphere, no pair of Dehn surgeries along distinct slopes are purely cosmetic, that is, none of them yield 3-manifolds those are orientation-preservingly homeomorphic. In this paper, we show that alternating knots having reduced alternating diagram with the twist number at least 7, Montesinos knots of length at least 5, and alternating Montesinos knots of length at least 4 do not admit purely cosmetic surgeries. As a corollary, we see that large alternating Montesinos knots have no purely cosmetic surgeries.

Geometric Topology
Cosmetic surgeries and non-orientable surfaces

Kazuhiro Ichihara

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1209.0103

2012-09-01

Geometric Topology

Abstract:By considering non-orientable surfaces in the surgered manifolds, we show that the 10/3- and -10/3-Dehn surgeries on the 2-bridge knot $9_{27} = S(49,19)$ are not cosmetic, i.e., they give mutually non-homeomorphic manifolds. The knot is unknown to have no cosmetic surgeries by previously known results; in particular, by using the Casson invariant and the Heegaard Floer homology.
The purely cosmetic surgery conjecture is true for the Kinoshita-Terasaka and Conway knot families

Bryan Boehnke,Conan Gillis,Hanwen Liu,Shuhang Xue

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2009.00522

2020-09-01

Geometric Topology

Abstract:We show that all nontrivial members of the Kinoshita-Terasaka and Conway knot families satisfy the purely cosmetic surgery conjecture.
Heegaard Floer homology and chirally cosmetic surgeries

Konstantinos Varvarezos

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2112.03144

2021-12-06

Geometric Topology

Abstract:A pair of surgeries on a knot is chirally cosmetic if they result in homeomorphic manifolds with opposite orientations. We find new obstructions to the existence of such surgeries coming from Heegaard Floer homology; in particular, we make use of immersed curve formulations of knot Floer homology and the corresponding surgery formula. As an application, we completely classify chirallly cosmetic surgeries on odd alternating pretzel knots, and we rule out such surgeries for a large class of Whitehead doubles. Furthermore, we rule out cosmetic surgeries for L-space knots along slopes with opposite signs.
A non-torus positive 2-bridge knot does not admit chirally cosmetic surgeries

Tetsuya Ito

2023-11-06

Abstract:We prove that a positive two-bridge knot other than the $(2,k)$ torus knot does not admit chirally cosmetic surgeries, a pair of Dehn surgeries along distinct slopes yielding orientation-reversingly homeomorphic 3-manifolds.

Geometric Topology
Cosmetic surgery on satellite knots

Qiuyu Ren

2024-11-21

Abstract:We show that if there exists a knot in $S^3$ that admits purely cosmetic surgeries, then there exists a hyperbolic one with this property.

Geometric Topology
Chirally Cosmetic Surgeries and Casson Invariants

Kazuhiro ICHIHARA,ITO Tetsuya,Toshio SAITO,Tetsuya ITO

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3836/tjm/1502179325

2021-01-01

Tokyo Journal of Mathematics

Abstract:We study chirally cosmetic surgeries, that is, a pair of Dehn surgeries on a knot producing homeomorphic 3-manifolds with opposite orientations. Several constraints on knots and surgery slopes to admit such surgeries are given. Our main ingredients are the original and the ${\rm SL}(2,\mathbb{C})$ version of Casson invariants. As applications, we give a complete classification of chirally cosmetic surgeries on alternating knots of genus one.

mathematics
Heegaard Floer homology and cosmetic surgeries in $S^3$

Jonathan Hanselman

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1906.06773

2020-08-29

Abstract:If a knot $K$ in $S^3$ admits a pair of truly cosmetic surgeries, we show that the surgery slopes are either $\pm 2$ or $\pm 1/q$ for some value of $q$ that is explicitly determined by the knot Floer homology of $K$. Moreover, in the former case the genus of $K$ must be two, and in the latter case there is bound relating $q$ to the genus and the Heegaard Floer thickness of $K$. As a consequence, we show that the cosmetic crossing conjecture holds for alternating knots (or more generally, Heegaard Floer thin knots) with genus not equal to two. We also show that the conjecture holds for any knot $K$ for which each prime summand of $K$ has at most 16 crossings; our techniques rule out cosmetic surgeries in this setting except for slopes $\pm 1$ and $\pm 2$ on a small number of knots, and these remaining examples can be checked by comparing hyperbolic invariants. These results make use of the surgery formula for Heegaard Floer homology, which has already proved to be a powerful tool for obstructing cosmetic surgeries; we get stronger obstructions than previously known by considering the full graded theory. We make use of a new graphical interpretation of knot Floer homology and the surgery formula in terms of immersed curves, which makes the grading information we need easier to access.

Geometric Topology
A remark on a finiteness of purely cosmetic surgeries

Tetsuya Ito

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2104.07922

2021-04-16

Geometric Topology

Abstract:By estimating the Turaev genus or the dealternation number, which leads to an estimate of knot floer thickness, in terms of the genus and the braid index, we show that a knot $K$ in $S^{3}$ does not admit purely cosmetic surgery whenever $g(K)\geq \frac{3}{2}b(K)$, where $g(K)$ and $b(K)$ denotes the genus and the braid index, respectively. In particular, this establishes a finiteness of purely cosmetic surgeries; for fixed $b$, all but finitely many knots with braid index $b$ satisfies the cosmetic surgery conjecture.
Cosmetic contact surgeries along transverse knots and the knot complement problem

Marc Kegel

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1703.05596

2019-02-02

Abstract:We study cosmetic contact surgeries along transverse knots in the standard contact 3-sphere, i.e. contact surgeries that yield again the standard contact 3-sphere. The main result is that we can exclude non-trivial cosmetic contact surgeries along all transverse knots not isotopic to the transverse unknot with self-linking number -1. As a corollary it follows that every transverse knot in the standard contact 3-sphere is determined by the contactomorphism type of its exteriors. Moreover, we give counterexamples to this for transverse links in the standard contact 3-sphere.

Geometric Topology,Symplectic Geometry
Chirally Cosmetic Surgeries on Kinoshita-Terasaka and Conway knot families

Xiliu Yang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2209.10723

2022-09-22

Geometric Topology

Abstract:In this note, we prove that a nontrivial Kinoshita-Terasaka or Conway knot does not admit chirally cosmetic surgeries, by calculating the finite type invariant of order 3.
Positive 2-bridge knots and chirally cosmetic surgeries

Michael Huang,Zelong Li,Rahi Tanaz,Chengyi Zhang

2023-08-23

Abstract:In this paper we verify that with the exception of the $(2, 2n+1)$ torus knots, positive 2-bridge knots up to 31 crossings do not admit chirally cosmetic surgeries. A knot $K$ admits chirally cosmetic surgeries if there exist surgeries $S^3_r$ and $S^3_{r'}$ with distinct slopes $r$ and $r'$ such that $S^3_r(K) \cong -S^3_{r'}(K)$, where the negative represents an orientation reversal. To verify this, we use the obstruction formula from <a class="link-https" data-arxiv-id="2112.03144" href="https://arxiv.org/abs/2112.03144">arXiv:2112.03144</a> which relates classical knot invariants to the existence of chirally cosmetic surgeries. To check the formula, we develop a Python program that computes the classical knot invariants $a_2$, $a_4$, $v_3$, $\det$, and $g$ of a positive 2-bridge knot.

Geometric Topology
Infinitely many knots admitting the same integer surgery

John Luecke,John Osoinach

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1407.1529

2014-07-07

Abstract:The construction of knots via annular twisting has been used to create families of knots yielding the same manifold via Dehn surgery. Prior examples have all involved Dehn surgery where the surgery slope is an integral multiple of 2. In this note we prove that for any integer $n$ there exist infinitely many different knots in $S^3$ such that $n$-surgery on those knots yields the same manifold. In particular, when $|n|=1$ homology spheres arise from these surgeries. In addition, when $n \neq 0$ the bridge numbers of the knots constructed tend to infinity as the number of twists along the annulus increases.

Geometric Topology

Purely cosmetic surgeries and pretzel knots

Alternating odd pretzel knots and chirally cosmetic surgeries

3-braid knots do not admit purely cosmetic surgeries

Connected sums of knots do not admit purely cosmetic surgeries

Cable knots do not admit cosmetic surgeries

Excluding cosmetic surgeries on hyperbolic 3-manifolds

Cosmetic surgery on knots

Special alternating knots with sufficiently many twist regions have no chirally cosmetic surgeries

Large alternating Montesinos knots do not admit purely cosmetic surgeries

Cosmetic surgeries and non-orientable surfaces

The purely cosmetic surgery conjecture is true for the Kinoshita-Terasaka and Conway knot families

Heegaard Floer homology and chirally cosmetic surgeries

A non-torus positive 2-bridge knot does not admit chirally cosmetic surgeries

Cosmetic surgery on satellite knots

Chirally Cosmetic Surgeries and Casson Invariants

Heegaard Floer homology and cosmetic surgeries in $S^3$

A remark on a finiteness of purely cosmetic surgeries

Cosmetic contact surgeries along transverse knots and the knot complement problem

Chirally Cosmetic Surgeries on Kinoshita-Terasaka and Conway knot families

Positive 2-bridge knots and chirally cosmetic surgeries

Infinitely many knots admitting the same integer surgery