COVID-19 Related Mobility Reduction: Heterogenous Effects on Sleep and Physical Activity Rhythms

J.L. Ong,T.Y. Lau,S.A.A. Massar,Z.T. Chong,B.K.L. Ng,D. Koek,W. Zhao,B.T.T. Yeo,K. Cheong,M.W.L. Chee

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2006.02100

2020-07-14

Abstract:Mobility restrictions imposed to suppress coronavirus transmission can alter physical activity (PA) and sleep patterns. Characterization of response heterogeneity and their underlying reasons may assist in tailoring customized interventions. We obtained wearable data covering baseline, incremental movement restriction and lockdown periods from 1824 city-dwelling, working adults aged 21 to 40 years, incorporating 206,381 nights of sleep and 334,038 days of PA. Four distinct rest activity rhythms (RARs) were identified using k-means clustering of participants' temporally distributed step counts. Hierarchical clustering of the proportion of time spent in each of these RAR revealed 4 groups who expressed different mixtures of RAR profiles before and during the lockdown. Substantial but asymmetric delays in bedtime and waketime resulted in a 24 min increase in weekday sleep duration with no loss in sleep efficiency. Resting heart rate declined 2 bpm. PA dropped an average of 38%. 4 groups with different compositions of RAR profiles were found. Three were better able to maintain PA and weekday/weekend differentiation during lockdown. The least active group comprising 51 percent of the sample, were younger and predominantly singles. Habitually less active already, this group showed the greatest reduction in PA during lockdown with little weekday/weekend differences. Among different mobility restrictions, removal of habitual social cues by lockdown had the largest effect on PA and sleep. Sleep and resting heart rate unexpectedly improved. RAR evaluation uncovered heterogeneity of responses to lockdown and can identify characteristics of persons at risk of decline in health and wellbeing.

Quantitative Methods

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: How did the mobility restriction measures implemented during the COVID - 19 pandemic affect the sleep patterns and physical activities of the urban working population? Specifically, the study aims to characterize the different responses of different sociodemographic groups to mobility restrictions by analyzing the sleep and activity data of these groups before and after the pandemic, and to explore the potential reasons for these changes. This helps to develop customized interventions for specific groups to improve their health and well - being.

The research background indicates that due to the spread of COVID - 19, various mobility restriction measures have been implemented globally, which have greatly changed people's daily living habits, especially the living structure of urban residents. These restriction measures may affect people's sleep quality and physical activity levels, and thus affect health and well - being. However, there are few studies on the sleep and physical activities of the general working population after the lockdown, especially longitudinal studies from the perspective of objective data are even scarcer.

To fill this research gap, this study utilized data collected from wearable devices (such as Fitbit) of about 1,800 office workers, covering the period from before the outbreak of the pandemic to the gradual implementation of mobility restrictions until the full lockdown. By analyzing these data, the study not only described the changes in objective measurements of sleep and physical activities in the entire sample, but also used the new Rest Activity Rhythm (RAR) and hierarchical clustering methods to show the impacts on groups with different sociodemographic characteristics.

The study found that although it was generally expected that the lockdown would lead to a decline in sleep quality, in fact, the sleep time was extended, while physical activities were significantly reduced. In addition, by analyzing the RAR of different groups, the study revealed the heterogeneous patterns in sleep and physical activities exhibited by different groups in the face of the lockdown. These findings are of great significance for identifying groups that may be at health risks during further or extended lockdowns.